City of York Council failures need urgent attention – Yorkshire Post Letters

From: Julian Sturdy, Conservative MP for York Outer.

The governance of York City Council continues to be called into question.

HAVING been a strong supporter of the alternative East-West model, I am understandably disappointed that Ministers didn’t grasp the overdue chance to overhaul local government in North Yorkshire and York with a once in a generation opportunity to fix decades-old failures.

I would like to be very clear that the decision to keep City of York Council in its current form should not be seen as an endorsement.

Sign up to our daily newsletter

The i newsletter cut through the noise

How could it be? Having been the subject of two (out of a total of five issued to upper tier councils since 2016) Public Interest Reports in recent years, which did not initiate any change or reforms to fix the errors highlighted, the council remains unfit for purpose.

What does the creation of a North Yorkshire super-council mean for York?

Officers and the councillors serving on the governing executive continue to betray local residents as long as they turn a blind eye to these failures.

Furthermore, the arguments for East-West remain relevant and without any change City of York Council will always be too small to ever provide efficient service – in both delivery and cost.

This has never been more obvious than in recent weeks when face to face services continue to remain limited and green waste bins haven’t been collected for weeks under the excuse of coronavirus, whereas other local authorities have been able to adapt to these challenges by continuing to deliver front-line services.

I want to be clear that I love York and firmly believe it to be the greatest city in the world, but our local authority boundaries do not define us. York has a loud enough voice to have not feared joining with Ryedale, Selby, and Scarborough but the decision has now been made.

Focus now must be on improving City of York Council and ensuring it works for residents before looking ahead to the proposed devolution deal which has the potential to deliver jobs and major investment for our city. I will continue to lobby for what I think is best for York and putting my constituents at the forefront of every decision I make.

From: Peter Rickaby, West Park, Selby.

CAN ratepayers in Selby, Craven, Harrogate, Richmondshire and Ryedale areas, now to be amalgamated into one local government district, expect a reduction in CEOs and councillors, all in the interest of efficiency and cost savings? Or is it going to be one huge unmanageable, overstaffed, bureaucratic nightmare?

Support The Yorkshire Post and become a subscriber today. Your subscription will help us to continue to bring quality news to the people of Yorkshire. In return, you’ll see fewer ads on site, get free access to our app and receive exclusive members-only offers. Click here to subscribe.