Why I am opposed to moving away from trials by jury - Yorkshire Post Letters

From: John Cole, Baildon, Shipley.

I acknowledge that there is a problem with a huge backlog (78.000) of cases awaiting to come to trial. The former senior judge, Lord Leveson, has floated the idea that cases where the accused, if found guilty, is likely to receive a custodial sentence of two years or less, might be decided by a judge, sitting without a jury.

Government ministers are talking about upping that bar to five years – that would be to further reduce the use of juries significantly. This, not surprisingly, has drawn considerable opposition. May I add to that opposition?

I cite the case of Clive Ponting, a civil servant, who came across secret documents that showed that government statements to the Commons about the sinking of the Argentinian warship ‘The Belgrano’ were false. Ponting passed these documents to a senior Labour MP, who blew the gaff on the government.

A general view of a public gallery inside at a courtroom. PIC: Jordan Pettitt/PA Wireplaceholder image
A general view of a public gallery inside at a courtroom. PIC: Jordan Pettitt/PA Wire

Ponting was put on trial for contravening the Official Secrets Act. He expected to be found guilty (indeed the government had hand-picked the trial judge, Sir Anthony McCowan, known to be a supporter of the establishment). True to form, Sir Anthony directed the jury to find Ponting guilty, but the jury returned a “not guilty” verdict.

Ponting's defence was that disclosure of the government's misleading of the Commons was “in the public interest”. The jury agreed with that - forming the basis of their “not guilty” verdict, to which they stuck despite the judge's assertion that : "the public interest is what the government of the day says it is".

I see this as a triumph of the jury system. Thanks to the jury Clive Ponting was able to receive the just verdict that the judge, if operating solo, would have denied him.

News you can trust since 1754
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice