Brierley Homes: Call for council director who chairs struggling firm to step down due to 'conflict of interest'
A Green councillor says a director who chairs a struggling council-owned commercial housebuilding company should step aside due to a conflict of interest.
The Yorkshire Post revealed that North Yorkshire Council’s wholly-owned firm Brierley Homes had an "urgent" request for an extra £1.4m loan approved last month, bringing the total borrowed to around £24m.
The loan was originally due to be paid back in March, but the deadline was extended last year by council bosses to 2028.
The council’s deputy leader Gareth Dadd signed off the “additional loan facility” on July 21.


The decision is due to be rubberstamped by the council’s Executive on August 19.
A report says the cash was needed urgently “due to a number of expected sales not being received in mid-July, in order to ensure suppliers could be paid on time.”
The firm was set up in 2016 by the former county council to build and sell homes with the profits being reinvested into frontline services.
It is expected to register losses of £3.2m for the financial year 2024/2025. It also owes £2.3m of unpaid interest to the council.
The Greens said Brierley Homes “are framing this as an investment in increased affordable housing (but) the council’s report indicates it’s just cash flow for misjudged sales income, slow delivery, and a lack of contingency planning”.
Green councillor and businessman Arnold Warneken said: “I’m deeply concerned that officers have been making these huge loans and subsidies to a private company behind closed doors.
"If they want public funding, there must be public scrutiny."
Coun Warneken said “through no fault of his own (company chair and NYC corporate director for environment Karl Battersby) is compromised because there is an obvious conflict of interest.
“He should be removed and let Brierley Homes have a chair that doesn’t have that conflict.”
He said the report needed more information about alternatives including ceasing trading, adding: “It’s got to be an option. It is taxpayers’ money.”
Independent councillors on North Yorkshire Council have also questioned the need for the council to provide further support to the developer.
Councillor Stuart Parsons, leader of the Independent group, said the additional funding was been provided at a time when the council was facing a multi-million pound shortfall in its budget.
He added: “How many more ‘unforeseen circumstances’ will there be requiring the council to find £2, £3m or £4m? We don’t have any confidence that this assistance will be the last made by the authority.
“It’s a concerning business – it’s the age-old problem that local authorities aren’t any good at running businesses.”
North Yorkshire Council’s chief executive, Richard Flinton, said: “Karl’s corporate director responsibilities do not include housing or planning matters, which ensures separation from potential areas of conflict.
“All of our directors follow the legal requirements set out in the Companies Act 2006, including the duty to avoid conflicts of interest and are bound by the rules and regulations governing company conduct and director responsibilities.
“In addition, Karl receives regular update training.”
