Councillors voted 11 to one at the meeting last Thursday, backing officers’ recommendation of refusal for Coun Paul Lisseter’s Williamsfield Developments scheme.
At the meeting Coun John Whittle said he thought the officers had it “absolutely right”.
The scheme – which sparked 30 objections – was an amended resubmission of an application, which was refused in 2018 and dismissed on appeal in 2019.
Officers said the plans – an extension to a scheme which has already seen 30 homes built – was contrary to the Local Plan.
However, Coun Lisseter said homes on his site were more affordable than others in the village, and would be built to high energy efficient standards.
Coun Lisseter said there was a local shortfall in housing. He said: "The council basically claim there isn't a need for extra land in Hutton Cranswick at the moment.
"Many people in Hutton Cranswick will find that rather strange as they are consulting on allocating another 124 houses (as part of the updated local plan) and yet they say there's no need for our extra 67."