Banned from pubs and backbench unrest: inside Labour's latest U-turn

First came the winter fuel payment U-turn, then there was the inheritance tax row back and now it appears something similar is planned for tax rises on pubs.

In the end, with pressure from backbenchers on all wings of the Labour Party, hiking business rates on hospitality businesses was not something the Treasury could ride out.

Once again, Rachel Reeves finds herself having to make changes to a policy she announced in the Budget less than two months ago.

The Chancellor had announced major reforms to the business rates, which is a tax on businesses based on the size of their property.

The plans had been to redirect some of the costs from Britain’s struggling high streets to the online giants, who so far have been paying much less.

However, it now appears that a change in the rateable value of properties, which had not been updated in years, ended up pushing up the cost on pubs, restaurants and hotels.

Figures provided by UKHospitality suggested hotels faced an average increase in business rates of 115 per cent by 2030, compared with a 76 per cent increase for pubs.

This comes after businesses had previously been hit by hikes in National Insurance contributions and the minimum wage.

Tommy Banks, who runs the Michelin-starred Black Swan in Oldstead and the Abbey Inn in Byland, told The Yorkshire Post: “The revaluation has been really difficult.

Chancellor of the Exchequer Rachel Reeves poses with the red Budget Box as she leaves 11 Downing Street on November 26 to present the government's annual Budget to Parliament.placeholder image
Chancellor of the Exchequer Rachel Reeves poses with the red Budget Box as she leaves 11 Downing Street on November 26 to present the government's annual Budget to Parliament. | Getty

“We’ve seen increases across the board, but The Black Swan has been hit the hardest — its business rates have effectively doubled.

“That means finding an extra £2,500 a month compared to last year, which is extremely challenging when margins are already tight.”

The 3 Acres Inn, near Huddersfield, would also have seen its business rates nearly double.

“We’re fortunate to have a strong reputation and to be busy, but if somewhere like The Abbey Inn didn’t have that profile and was simply a small business run by a couple, there’s no chance those additional rates would be manageable,” Mr Banks added.

Findings from the British Beer and Pub Association (BPPA) last year had already revealed that Yorkshire was one of the hardest hit places in the UK for pub closures.

Some 258 pubs have closed since 2016 and a further 260 are at risk without "meaningful" reform.

Skipton and Ripon MP Sir Julian Smith explained: “Hospitality businesses are still recovering from Covid, with many lost during that period.

“Following all of that cumulative impact, increasing business rates hits really hard.

Sir Julian Smith, Conservative MP for Skipton and Ripon, has warned that a proposed tourism tax would be a “hammer blow” for hospitality businesses in North Yorkshireplaceholder image
Sir Julian Smith, Conservative MP for Skipton and Ripon, has warned that a proposed tourism tax would be a “hammer blow” for hospitality businesses in North Yorkshire

“Publicans are telling us they are going to give up or, equally worrying, previously highly profitable pubs are unable to make a profit.

“There are lots of reasons for that - energy costs, staffing costs, input costs on food - but issues like rates are coming as a quadruple whammy.”

In the Chancellor’s seat 37 pubs have closed in the market town of Pudsey since 2016.

So it was no surprise that amid the potential for more tax rises some publicans reacted with anger, with Martin Knowles, who runs the Marsh Inn, in Pudsey, erecting a sign saying all Labour MPs – including Ms Reeves – are barred.

He said "they are not doing our industry any favours at all" - adding that his premises would have been hit with a £2,500 hike in business rates.

He said his clientele seemed “quite happy” with the ban, and added the Chancellor would be welcomed back if she stopped business rates going "through the roof", lowered VAT and PAYE, and stopped increasing the minimum wage.

Amid this kind of backlash, it felt some sort of U-turn was inevitable.

Backbench MPs were bringing local landlords into the Treasury to meet Ms Reeves, and spell out the impact of the business rates rise.

Another gem by Tommy Banks, this restaurant offers a farm-to-table experience with a Michelin star.placeholder image
Another gem by Tommy Banks, this restaurant offers a farm-to-table experience with a Michelin star. | National World

The prognosis for many was possible closure, with Northern MPs warning that it was a gift to Reform ahead of May’s local elections.

It appears Ms Reeves was already looking at possible changes before Christmas.

Sources indicated the Chancellor commissioned work on providing more support for pubs, after the budget’s impact on individual sectors began to become clear in Government analysis.

The Treasury had already put in place a £4.3bn fund to help pubs with the transition to higher rates, but it is understood more assistance will now be made available.

It is understood that Ms Reeves will announce a package of support in the coming days, likely to include business rates relief and measures to cut licensing red tape.

Shoppers pictured on the Shambles, York. PIC: Simon Hulmeplaceholder image
Shoppers pictured on the Shambles, York. PIC: Simon Hulme

Kate Nicholls, chairwoman of UKHospitality, has called for “a hospitality-wide solution”, saying the entire industry is affected by business rate hikes, not just pubs.

In York, both MP Rachael Maskell and Mayor David Skaith have raised concerns about the impact on independent shops on the city's iconic high street.

Yesterday, Labour Party Chair and Redcar MP Anna Turley insisted these changes were a sign of strength for the Government.

“I don’t buy this is a U-turn. This is actually about listening,” she said.

“I think it’s a sign of a Government that is actually in touch with people, that is listening to people, and that is responding.”

She added: “I think listening to constituents isn’t being bullied or lobbied – that’s what we’re here to do.

“We’re here to represent the people that we live amongst and, if a policy isn’t right, I think it’s a sign of a confident Government that says, ‘do you know what? we’ll step in, we’ll sort it out, we’ll make sure it works’.”

Conservative Party Chair Kevin Hollinrake, who is also the MP for Thirsk and Malton, added: “We still don’t know what the Government’s plan is, but all the signs are that pubs will keep paying more and this package does nothing for shops, restaurants, hotels and market traders across North Yorkshire who’ve already seen their bills rise since the Budget.”

News you can trust since 1754
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice