Exclusive:'Delay' review into West Yorkshire mass transit project to be kept secret
An independent review into West Yorkshire’s mass transit system, which caused the scheme to be delayed to the late 2030s, will remain shrouded in secrecy, with the publication now restricted for legal reasons.
The review, by the National Infrastructure and Service Transformation Authority (Nista) with West Yorkshire Combined Authority (WYCA) and Department for Transport, led to a change in process on the project.
Previously WYCA was attempting to work on the business case and the planning process at the same time to speed up the timeframe, however the review advised it to focus on the former first.
It put together a “robust, sequential timeline” and advised on “derisking our delivery of the overall programme”, according to mass transit director Mike Birch.
This led to the estimated completion dates of the two routes - one from Leeds to Bradford and the second to the White Rose Centre via Elland Road - being delayed until the late 2030s.


At a press conference in December, Ms Brabin told reporters, including The Yorkshire Post, that a summary of the review would be published in January as part of WYCA board papers.
However it has now emerged that this will remain secret, with the DfT saying that all major project reviews undertaken by Nista are treated as confidential.
It is understood the Government believes this will help provide honest feedback.
A WYCA spokesperson said: “Following legal advice, we are unable to release the report or details of its contents.
“The report contains information relating to financial or business affairs and disclosure at this stage could inhibit full and frank discussions about the project.
“It will still be shared with Combined Authority members to enable them to scrutinise and provide constructive challenge as we move forward with delivery of the Mass Transit programme.”
This is only likely to fuel further scepticism with the project, with previous tram and trolleybus schemes in Leeds scrapped before any construction work started.
Tom Forth, co-founder of Leeds-based tech company The Data City, said: “It’s as fundamental as democracy doesn’t work if we, the people, cannot read what the experts and the Government are thinking and doing.
“How do I know whose fault it is that this scheme could take 17 years to complete?”
Mr Forth, who was previously an expert on DfT’s capital investment panel, added: “At some point I and the million voters in West Yorkshire need to know so we can decide who to vote for.”
However, this week Chancellor Rachel Reeves told this paper: “There will be trams. Mass transit does not mean a few better buses, mass transit means a tram network.”
A DfT spokesperson said: “We are working closely with the West Yorkshire Mayor to deliver a mass transit system, boosting connectivity and unlocking growth and opportunity for the region.
"We are already funding the first phase through their Transport for City Regions allocation, and we recently committed to funding its delivery beyond this tranche.”
