Doncaster Sheffield Airport: Auditors’ ‘conflict of interest’ concerns over council officers’ places on airport board
The City of Doncaster Council’s external auditors have recommended the authority take advice over potential conflicts of interest arising by having senior officers on the board of its Doncaster Sheffield Airport company.
Two of the council’s top officials are registered as directors of Fly Doncaster Ltd, the arms-length company established by the local authority to run Doncaster Sheffield Airport (DSA) upon re-opening.
Grant Thornton, the external auditors for Doncaster Council, outlined a new report on the council for members of the authority’s Audit Committee on Wednesday, November 26, 2025.
Georgia Jones, from Grant Thornton, said their report was a “retrospective look” at arrangements in place at the council up until March 31, 2025.


She said the report, rubberstamped last week, raised concerns about the positions of council chief executive Damian Allen and executive director for corporate resources, Debbie Hogg, as directors of Fly Doncaster Ltd.
“It’s a big project for the council and there will be risk around that project, whether that’s financial or reputational,” Ms Jones said.
She added: “Often what you need when you have a company linked to the council, you need that separation of governance between the two and the separation of key officers.
“Even if you try to stay objective, if you’re an officer of the council does the council’s interests prevail, or if you’re also sitting on the board of the company, does the company interest prevail.
“It’s making that recommendation around making sure that conflict of interest isn’t real or even perceived in terms of reputational risk.”
Ms Jones said that Grant Thornton had raised the issue, despite the fact Fly Doncaster Ltd had been dormant, due to the fact they had not seen an interest from Doncaster Council to change the arrangements between the two entities.
However, Ms Jones said the council had agreed to undertake advice around the issue, which was described as “helpful”.
The report includes an explanation from the council as to why Mr Allen and Ms Hogg were on the board of directors for Fly Doncaster Ltd.
It read: “Careful consideration has been given as to where to risk and control can be exercised most effectively. Management have considered these matters and formed a judgement, which has been reinforced through political discussions, that the chief executive and executive director of resources should maintain the tight control and be as close to the decision making as possible.
“It is for this reason that the chief executive and executive director of resources are best placed to exercise these controls on behalf of CDC by being directors of FlyDoncaster Ltd.”
It further says this position will remain “under review” and “amended at the earliest opportunity, anticipated once the initial reopening risks have passed”.
Grant Thornton also stated that Doncaster Council needed to do “more detailed work” and “refine” its business case for the airport.
Ms Jones told the committee: “For us as auditors, we would like to see a financial risk limit that the council is accepting.”
She explained that in some cases, though clarified this was not the case in Doncaster at present, authorities undertaking significant projects are too slow to cut their losses when things do not work out.
“Sometimes with these big projects, a lot of money goes into it and then if it does start to go wrong at what point do you draw a line and say ‘right, we’re pulling out’,” Ms Jones said.
“The temptation always is ‘we’ve put all this money in, we can’t let it go, we need to put more in’, so you need that idea of where do you draw the line. Where is your off-ramp,” she added.
The external auditors said the council needed these measures and controls in place in order to best protect the authority.
Grant Thornton were said to be happy with the actions being taken from the present time by Doncaster Council and would be “following up” on these during their 2025/26 work with the authority.