'Final showdown' in bid to stop motorway services

VILLAGERS are gearing up for a “final showdown” in their fight against a motorway service station that has already been denied by local planners.
Gareth Owens and Councillor Nick Brown at Applegreens proposed site. Picture: Kirby Hill RAMSGareth Owens and Councillor Nick Brown at Applegreens proposed site. Picture: Kirby Hill RAMS
Gareth Owens and Councillor Nick Brown at Applegreens proposed site. Picture: Kirby Hill RAMS

Motorway service station company Applegreen say a proposed development off the A1M at Kirby Hall near Boroughbridge would add £6m to the local economy and create more than 300 jobs.

But members of Harrogate Borough Council’s planning committee refused the application in November, after more than 150 people objected to it.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Residents in the right over A1M service station fight – The Yorkshire Post saysLast month Applegreen appealed the decision, and it is set to go before a public inquiry by the planning inspectorate in June.

Protestors hope to travel to Dublin for Applegreens AGM in May. Picture: Kirby Hill RAMSProtestors hope to travel to Dublin for Applegreens AGM in May. Picture: Kirby Hill RAMS
Protestors hope to travel to Dublin for Applegreens AGM in May. Picture: Kirby Hill RAMS

The plans represent the fifth attempt to build a rest stop in the area near Boroughbridge in the last 24 years.

Campaign group Kirby Hill RAMS (Residents Against Motorway Services), who have submitted a written statement to the inquiry again objecting to the plans, said the scheme is "socially and environmentally irresponsible", would cause substantial harm to the open countryside and the environment at Kirby Hill, and to the economy of the nearby market town of Boroughbridge.

Members of the group say they might even travel to Dublin, where the company is based, to protest at

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Applegreen’s AGM in May, if coronavirus travel restrictions are lifted.

The proposed MSA site. Picture: Kirby Hill RAMSThe proposed MSA site. Picture: Kirby Hill RAMS
The proposed MSA site. Picture: Kirby Hill RAMS

RAMS’ chairman, Gareth Owens, said: “Kirby Hill is Britain’s most controversial proposed MSA (motorway service area) site for a good reason - it is a completely inappropriate location for this type of development, which would cause substantial harm.

“For 24 years, decision-makers in the planning system and in the courts have agreed with us. “Applegreen’s recent MSA planning application was the fifth to be refused. Harrogate Borough Council’s Planning Committee rejected the scheme, saying it was not sustainable development and that it would cause substantial harm to the open countryside, to the environment and to the economy of the nearby market town of Boroughbridge.

“This is not news to local people. We told Applegreen about the harm their plans would cause back in 2017, but we were ignored.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

“We feel very strongly that the company should now respect Harrogate Borough Council’s decision.”

Former Harrogate mayor Nick Brown, Conservative councillor for Bishop Monkton and Newby, whose ward includes the site, is opposed to the scheme.

He urged Applegreen to “take a really close look” at what they were doing.

“Speculatively ‘having a go’ at getting planning permission is one thing, but the Local Planning Authority has given six good reasons for refusal, on the back of four previous projects at this site that have gone the same way, three of them after Public Inquiry,” he said.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

“Given the current business climate, I don’t understand why Applegreen is continuing to invest in such a controversial project, with so little prospect of success, contrary to the social and environmental credentials they claim for their brand.

“If ever there was a time for management to cut their losses on this project, it is now.”

Applegreen’s chief development director, Eugene Moore, said; “Applegreen has lodged an appeal with the Planning Inspectorate to consider the planning decision for the Vale of York motorway service area proposals.

“We don’t believe it is appropriate to comment on the process further until the appeal has been heard.”

Comment Guidelines

National World encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.