Northern Powerhouse Rail has 'echoes of same failures seen in HS2', MPs warn

The Public Accounts Committee has questioned how the £45bn Treasury budget will deliver the long-awaited rail network connecting cities on both sides of the Pennines.

The failures of HS2 risk being repeated on the Northern Powerhouse Rail project, MPs have said, raising concerns that the company in charge of the disastrous rail scheme has been brought in to develop plans for the new lines.

In a major report published today, the Public Accounts Committee, which scrutinises Government spending, has questioned how the £45bn Treasury budget will deliver the long-awaited rail network connecting cities on both sides of the Pennines.

In January, Chancellor Rachel Reeves announced the latest version of this decades-long project, designed to create a “turn up and go” railway across the North that mirrors London’s transport network.

By the 2040s, she pledged there would be a new line from Liverpool to Manchester and into West Yorkshire, with simpler upgrades across the region being completed in the early 2030s.

This includes a new through station at Bradford, major improvements to Leeds station and electrification between Leeds and Sheffield.

Department for Transport officials have repeatedly insisted that lessons have been learnt from the disastrous HS2 project.

West Yorkshire Mayor Tracy Brabin, left, with Rachel Reeves at the Neville Hill TrainCare Depot in Leeds for the Northern Powerhouse Rail announcement. Credit: Danny Lawson/PA Wireplaceholder image
West Yorkshire Mayor Tracy Brabin, left, with Rachel Reeves at the Neville Hill TrainCare Depot in Leeds for the Northern Powerhouse Rail announcement. Credit: Danny Lawson/PA Wire | Danny Lawson/PA Wire

The high-speed rail network has had both legs to Manchester and Leeds cancelled and could cost more than £100bn by the time trains run from Euston to Birmingham in 2043.

It was initially estimated to cost £32.7bn in 2011 for the entire project, including both northern sections.

However, the PAC said it had observed “echoes of the same failures seen in HS2’s governance” that provoked particular concern.

MPs said they were worried that the system of working with mayors and local government will make it difficult to decide on the trade offs for prioritising different areas.

Sheffield MP Clive Betts condemned  a Reform UK candidate for “flirting with far right ideology.”placeholder image
Sheffield MP Clive Betts condemned a Reform UK candidate for “flirting with far right ideology.” | CB

The PAC also questioned why the DfT had appointed HS2 Ltd to develop plans for the line from Liverpool to Manchester, that would eventually go on to Huddersfield and Leeds, “given its track record of poor cost estimation”.

Clive Betts, the Sheffield South East MP and deputy chair of the PAC, said: “The government’s growth strategy earlier this year signalled that there is still an appetite to finally deliver the transport infrastructure the North so badly needs.

“But the spectre of HS2 hangs over Northern Powerhouse Rail. Our Committee has heard troubling echoes of the same mistakes in loose governance that HS2 made early on, and so much of the project remains almost impressionistic, 12 years on.

“HS2 have even been brought on board to develop NPR’s own plans. As HS2 has been a casebook example of how not to run a major project, so their involvement in NPR does not fill us with confidence.”

Mr Betts also questioned how the Government could be confident of the project fitting within the Treasury’s £45bn funding cap, when the sections had not been fully scoped out.

A member of HS2 staff walks into the Chilterns tunnel. PIC: Jonathan Brady/PA Wireplaceholder image
A member of HS2 staff walks into the Chilterns tunnel. PIC: Jonathan Brady/PA Wire

The North’s mayors will be required to provide additional funding, however West Yorkshire Mayor Tracy Brabin has already tried to push back on this as she is raising funds for the mass transit network.

“Capping a project’s funding before it was even designed or costed feels like putting a roof on a house before the foundations are even laid,” Mr Betts added.

A DfT spokesperson said that the focus with NPR would be on reliable, tried and tested delivery instead of expensive world-beating first, such as speeds of up to 250mph.

They said: "Northern Powerhouse Rail will deliver the biggest investment in rail connectivity in a generation, giving the North the transport links it deserves and driving growth, jobs and investment across the region.

"NPR will not repeat the mistakes of HS2 which is why we accepted all the recommendations of the James Stewart Review and are taking a disciplined, phased approach - completing detailed technical work with all stakeholders before fixing precise choices for major infrastructure.

"Since announcing NPR in January, we have worked closely with Mayors to take the project forward. New joint partnership forums are already overseeing the next stage of development and Network Rail has begun developing engineering designs."

News you can trust since 1754
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice