York councillors call to end 'outdated' voting system 'driving hate and division'

Changes are needed to restore trust in politics amid mounting division and distrust in the status quo, York councillors have said.

Councillors have called on the Government to ditch the current electoral system in favour of one which better represents the range of views among voters.

Opposition Liberal Democrat Coun Anne Hook said the current first past the post system saw parties win power with minority support while millions of votes did not count.

But Conservative Coun Chris Steward said all voting systems were flawed and a system of proportional representation would not end extremes in politics or safe seats for parties.

The entrance to York Council's headquarters at West Offices, Station Rise, Yorkplaceholder image
The entrance to York Council's headquarters at West Offices, Station Rise, York

Coun Hook’s motion calling for work looking at reforming the voting system in time for the next general election set to take place by 2029 was backed by councillors.

The motion passed at City of York Council’s full meeting on Thursday, March 26 states the authority’s preference would be for a form of proportional representation.

The call has also been backed locally by the campaign groups Compass North Yorkshire and Make Votes Matter and representatives of both organisations spoke at Thursday’s meeting.

Under the current first past the post system, the candidate or party which gets the most votes wins, even if they are not supported by an overall majority of electors.

There are various forms of proportional representation.

But they broadly operate in line with the principle that candidates or parties are awarded representation based on the share of the vote they each receive.

Councillors heard that the UK and Belarus were the only two countries in Europe that use single-round first past the post voting systems.

Most other European countries use a form of proportional representation.

The current national Labour government won 411 of the 650 seats in the House of Commons in 2024’s general election compared to an overall vote share of 34 per cent.

Liberal Democrat Coun Hook said moving to proportional representation would end the current system’s failure to reflect the share of votes received in the results.

Coun Hook said :”Proportional representation would raise the quality of discussion and force ideas to stand up to scrutiny and ensure policies command support beyond just a single party majority.

“The current system produces wild swings from one government to the next and longer term decisions are abandoned.”

Green Joe Nasson said the call for reform came as politics had become increasingly divisive.

Mr Nasson said: “Political rhetoric is driving hatred and division which is reflected on social media and peddled by tech billionaires for profit.

“When voters in elections aren’t represented in the results it’s easy to see where frustration in the system comes from.”

Labour’s Coun Tony Clarke said the Government was already making progress on reform in other areas including with plans to lower the voting age to 16 and scrap hereditary peers.

But he added the Government should go further.

Coun Clarke said: “A fairer voting system would contribute to restoring trust and engagement in the democratic process.”

Conservative Coun Steward said there were advantages and disadvantages to each system.

He added it was nonsense to say that proportional representation would fix all problems with the current system.

Coun Steward said: “First past the post isn’t perfect but we have to look at both systems objectively.

“It’s nonsense to sy there wouldn’t be any more safe seats or tactical voting. You would have more extremes with proportional representation.”

News you can trust since 1754
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice