Prison boss steps down amid safety fears at Yorkshire jail

The director of a privately-run East Yorkshire prison is being replaced less than a year in post after serious concerns were flagged over its operation.

It came after volunteers appointed to monitor conditions at HMP Millsike said they only felt safe to visit in pairs. They also highlighted poor security, with doors and gates left open, rampant drug use and “frequent reports of batons being drawn”.

The Independent Monitoring Board at HMP Millsike wrote to prisons minister Lord Timpson in December to raise concerns over the “safety and security” of the site.

Mitie took on its first prison contract to run the Category C prison, which opened last March.

Justice Secretary Shabana Mahmood during the official opening of HMP Millsike - the new Category C jail in Yorkshire which will deliver 1,500 prison places. Picture date: Thursday March 27, 2025. PAplaceholder image
Justice Secretary Shabana Mahmood during the official opening of HMP Millsike - the new Category C jail in Yorkshire which will deliver 1,500 prison places. Picture date: Thursday March 27, 2025. PA

The firm said director Samantha Pariser would be replaced by Sarah Mallender, director of Heathrow Immigration Removal Centre, in June. In the meantime, Paul Newton, a “well-respected veteran of prison operations” would take over as interim director.

HMP Millsike, which is built next to HMP Full Sutton has around 1,000 prisoners. At full capacity it will hold 1,468 inmates.

The Independent Monitoring Board (IMB) said roll calls were taking up to five hours, meaning prisoners locked in their cells longer and missing work, education and visits, with staff also missing out on breaks.

Board members said inmates “on constant watch have still been able to selfharm and make ligatures”.

Drugs were easily available and prisoners were saying they could easily make substances from items “supplied by the prison, such as floor cleaner”.

The board added: “Members are still observing, some eight months after opening, doors and gates being left open, inconsistent gate security and we currently only visit in pairs due to feeling unsafe on the wings, sentiments which are also felt by some healthcare staff.”

The IMB said it painted a “deeply concerning picture of the early operation of HMP Millsike and the human cost of current new prison opening models”.

It asked for clarity on extra support and scrutiny to ensure “prisoners are treated safely, fairly and humanely during the critical early years of operation”.

In a statement, Mitie did not refer to the IMB’s letter to Lord Timpson. It insisted Ms Pariser had been “instrumental in establishing a safe, and stable operational environment” at the jail.

Regarding her temporary replacement, Paul Newton, Mitie said: "Paul is a well-respected veteran of prison operations, with more than 35 years of experience, having served as Governing Governor at HMP Drake Hall, HMP Swaleside, HMP Birmingham and most recently at HMP Hewell.”

Mr Newton was brought in at HMP Birmingham in 2018. Described as a crisis-hit “hell-hole”, dubbed the worst the chief inspector ever visited, he was credited with overseeing a "transformation" during his tenure.

Russell Trent, Mitie Care & Custody’s MD, said Ms Pariser had “laid strong foundations for the future” and she would take on a new strategic role with the firm.

He added: “As HMP Millsike continues to build up to full capacity, we remain committed to creating an environment that is focused on rehabilitation.” HM Prison Service runs 105 of the 122 prisons in England and Wales, with the rest privately-run

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1754
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice