The Craven Arms: Historic Dales pub reviving ancient tradition of beer in oak barrels

To landlord David Aynesworth there is no better feeling than that of crossing the moors with his old oak barrels of beer.

It is what centuries of pub owners have done before him, for The Craven Arms at Appletreewick. Once it would have been by horse and cart.

Now the 82-year-old, loading up his trusty Land Rover, travels a 44-mile round trip to Theakston Brewery in Masham each week.

Here he picks up three or four oak barrels of Old Peculiar to sell in the pub, some 216 pints. Each barrel is handcrafted by a resident cooper. They weigh a tonne.

“It is unusual,” he said. “And it's extra work to do it. But beer out of the oak barrels is very different to beer out of a metal cask. It imparts an extra flavour. To me it makes it softer, a deeper taste.”

Oak barrels such as these are harder to come by in Britain today. Mostly, beer comes in casks.

Picture: Lorne Campbell / Guzelian. Pub owner David Aynesworth enjoys a pint of Theakston's Old Peculiar beer in his pub, The Craven Arms at Appletreewick.placeholder image
Picture: Lorne Campbell / Guzelian. Pub owner David Aynesworth enjoys a pint of Theakston's Old Peculiar beer in his pub, The Craven Arms at Appletreewick.

Traditions, to Mr Aynesworth, are important. He used to be a Punch and Judy man, with his old puppets up on the shelf. Then a fiddler for a Morris troupe.

A chartered surveyor by trade, and former estate manager for Skipton's Broughton Hall, he took on the pub 20 years ago as joint landlord with son Robert. Now it a family venture, with wife Linda and daughter-in-law Ali who also runs shepherd's huts. They have returned it to the “old ways”.

There are paintings in the pub of oak barrels behind the bar from long ago. He's seen too many pubs, said Mr Aynesworth, stripped out and modernised. Out comes their "soul and heart".

Picture: Lorne Campbell / Guzelian. Every week David Aynesworth makes the 44 mile round trip to Theakston's Brewery in Masham , North Yorkshire, to pick up oak barrels of the beer to sell in his pub.placeholder image
Picture: Lorne Campbell / Guzelian. Every week David Aynesworth makes the 44 mile round trip to Theakston's Brewery in Masham , North Yorkshire, to pick up oak barrels of the beer to sell in his pub.

Here, he said, they've brought it back. There's a cruck barn, in traditional style from 1,000 years ago, with wooden pegs rather than nails and with local stone, thatch and trees. It uses a 'cruck', two halves of one tree, to form the timber frame. And then there's the oak barrels, behind the bar once more.

“People do like to see the old ways of life and the old ways of doing things,” he said.

“If ever I run out, there's hell to pay,” he added. “People come from all over for a pint. I make sure I don't run out.”

Picture: Lorne Campbell / Guzelian. Pub owner David Aynesworth pulls a pint of Theakston's Old Peculiar beer in his pub, the Craven Arms at Appletreewick, North Yorkshire. The 82 year old retired chartered surveyor said the oak barrels give it a deeper and softer taste.placeholder image
Picture: Lorne Campbell / Guzelian. Pub owner David Aynesworth pulls a pint of Theakston's Old Peculiar beer in his pub, the Craven Arms at Appletreewick, North Yorkshire. The 82 year old retired chartered surveyor said the oak barrels give it a deeper and softer taste.

The pub may be familiar to many people from television screens, used for the filming of shows such as All Creatures Great And Small and the film Emily about the Brontes.

It is wild up here at times. It's beautiful, added Mr Aynesworth.

"I don't think we're in the middle of nowhere," he insists. "We're at the centre of the world - it's everyone else that's far away."

Picture: Lorne Campbell / Guzelian. The Craven Arms was built in the 1600splaceholder image
Picture: Lorne Campbell / Guzelian. The Craven Arms was built in the 1600s

And his trips to Theakstons, following in the footsteps of landlords since the 17th century over Dallow Gill Moor, have become a weekly treat. They can trace the names of all who came before him.

"I love it," he said. "It gives me a bit of an escape. It's just a nice feeling, bringing the beer back over the moors."

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1754
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice