Anthony McGrath challenges Yorkshire CCC to discover consistency after morale-boosting win

WILL the real Yorkshire please stand up.

Was it the one that lost by 377 runs at Edgbaston last week, the second-heaviest defeat in the club's history in terms of runs, or was it the one that thrashed Surrey by an innings and 127 at Headingley on Monday?

Was it the one hammered by Hampshire in the first home match of the season, maybe, or the one that grabbed victory from the jaws of defeat at Somerset two weeks ago?

Played six, won two, drawn two, lost two. We have seen everything from Yorkshire in this first block of games.

FINISHING TOUCHES: Yorkshire's Jack White celebrates dismissing Surrey's Josh Blake on the fourth day of the County Championship clash between the two teams at Headingley. Picture: Allan McKenzie/SWpix.complaceholder image
FINISHING TOUCHES: Yorkshire's Jack White celebrates dismissing Surrey's Josh Blake on the fourth day of the County Championship clash between the two teams at Headingley. Picture: Allan McKenzie/SWpix.com

For Anthony McGrath, the club’s head coach, it is all about consistency.

“I keep saying it but consistency is what we need,” said McGrath, whose side captured the final five Surrey wickets to wrap up victory 20 minutes before lunch on day four.

“In the last seven days we’ve seen two completely different performances from us, so that’s now our challenge.

“We know at our best we can do what we did there against one of the best teams in the country, and at our worst that we can be very bad.

Jordan Clark has his off stump knocked out of the ground by Yorkshire's Jack White on day four at Headingley. Picture by Allan McKenzie/SWpix.complaceholder image
Jordan Clark has his off stump knocked out of the ground by Yorkshire's Jack White on day four at Headingley. Picture by Allan McKenzie/SWpix.com

“So we've just got to find ways, when we’re not going so well, of staying in games and being better when we’re at our worst.

“If we get that consistency, then we know what we can do.

"We know that they're all good players, and I think all of us, players and coaches, have been scratching our heads a bit as to why we've been so inconsistent.

“It would have been easy to be down and carry the hangover from what was a really poor performance at Edgbaston, but right from Wednesday, Thursday going into this game, everyone was really confident and I think from ball one we were pretty much dominant.”

INCONSISTENT: Yorkshire coach Anthony McGrath interviewed after victory over Surrey. Picture: Allan McKenzie/SWpix.complaceholder image
INCONSISTENT: Yorkshire coach Anthony McGrath interviewed after victory over Surrey. Picture: Allan McKenzie/SWpix.com

This was, first and foremost, an excellent response to that Warwickshire defeat.

Yorkshire were 137-4 in that game in reply to the home team’s 147, then lost their last six wickets for 15 runs, a momentum shift that they never got back.

Victory here was built on a big innings total of 486, to which Adam Lyth and Jonny Bairstow contributed fine hundreds, then backed up a splendid third day in the field – a defining day in the season, perhaps – when Yorkshire took 15 Surrey wickets as the visitors fell to 204 and then 83-5.

All of the bowlers contributed – George Hill with four wickets, Matty Revis three and Ben Cliff two in the first innings, then Jack White and Harry Brook with three apiece in the second leading the way, with Brook’s 3-11 a career-best return.

“Harry did look fairly dangerous when he bowled at Warwickshire but I couldn’t really say that after the match as we’d just conceded 500 in the second innings,” quipped McGrath.

“He probably thought that he was going to take the new ball this game, the way he’d been bowling.

“But, no, he was full of confidence, and to get the wickets he did, particularly Jamie Smith, who’s a good mate of his, is a feather in his cap.

“I’m sure they’ll be discussing that when they meet up with England in a few days’ time.”

The smell of cooked food was just beginning to drift up from the Hawke Suite on the third floor of the Headingley pavilion when Yorkshire bowled out Surrey for 155 second time round, inflicting on them their first innings defeat for almost two years.

Fittingly, it was George Hill, who had another fine match, who applied the coup de grace when he sent Dan Worrall’s off stump flying.

Right on cue, following an overcast morning with the floodlights on, the sun appeared as if in approval.

Surrey had resumed on 83-5 – still 199 short of making Yorkshire bat again – and they lost two early wickets as Dom Sibley edged Jhye Richardson to second slip, where Brook took the catch, moving to his left, then Josh Blake, the other overnight batsman, who fell lbw to White pushing forward.

Dom Bess spilled two catches at leg slip – Sibley off White (in a near-repeat of Sibley’s first innings dismissal), then Matthew Fisher off Hill – but it did not matter in the grand scheme of things.

White knocked out Jordan Clark’s off stump with a ball that kept a bit low (95-8), then Fisher – two balls after being struck on the helmet by a bouncer from Revis – edged Revis to first slip, where Joe Root took a good head-high catch.

“I'm just really pleased for everyone because it's not been through a lack of effort that we haven’t always got it right,” added McGrath.

“Everyone is really trying hard, and sometimes when you do that you can get a little bit anxious and a bit tentative.

“I'm just pleased that it all came together and it's a reward for a lot of hard work through the winter and in the last five games.

“Now we’ve got to make sure that when the Championship starts up again (in the middle of next month) that we’re right on it because this was a reminder of what we can do.”

News you can trust since 1754
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice