Sandpapergate: The stain on the game that won't go away
NOT even sandpaper could smooth away the splinters and rough edges left behind by one of the game's greatest scandals.


Sandpapergate is here to stay – a stain on the sport that refuses to fade.
Eight years after the Australians smuggled sandpaper onto the field to tamper with the ball in South Africa, we are still talking about it.
And we will still be talking about it eight years from now – and another eight years after that, and so on.


The chances of this saga ever reaching a definitive conclusion seem remote, short of everyone involved being given truth serum.
In recent days, the debate has been reignited by a series of conflicting accounts, beginning with the publication of Usman Khawaja's book.
Khawaja alleged that the entire team knew about the plot to tamper with the ball – not just Steve Smith, David Warner and Cameron Bancroft, the men who took the hit.
In response, Pat Cummins, the Australia Test captain, dismissed the allegation as nonsense, before Chadd Sayers, the 12th man, backed Khawaja’s version.
By the time you read this, no doubt someone else will have weighed in. And on it will go, ad infinitum.
It is difficult to see how another investigation would change the narrative of this sorry affair.
Cricket Australia’s initial inquiry seems to have been considerably less thorough than it should have been, with a line drawn in the sand – if not the sandpaper – within a matter of days, followed by lengthy suspensions for Smith, Warner and Bancroft.
Perhaps evidence collected at the time could now be released, although that might equally serve only to highlight the shortcomings of the investigation, such as it was.
There have been suggestions that NDAs might have been signed by some of the officials and parties involved, while the players and coaches would presumably continue to stand by their respective versions of events. In short, the horse has bolted.
What was an intensely embarrassing episode for Australian cricket in 2018, and a significant blow to national pride, has become an enduring source of humiliation.
The idea that a single version of events, acceptable to the Australian public and the cricketing world, can ever be established seems pie in the sky. Anyone looking for closure is unlikely to find it here.
And yet there is closure in another way: on one of the ugliest teams to have tarnished the sport. A team Cummins admitted was arrogant and abrasive. A team that resorted to such bare-faced deception in the first place.
One is reminded of Brian Clough’s famous put-down of his Leeds United players: they could throw all their medals in the bin because they had won them by cheating.
No doubt Old Big ‘Ead – a keen cricket fan himself – would have had plenty to say about Steve Smith’s crew.
Sandpapergate was the embodiment of Australian arrogance, the feeling that they could get away with anything on the field.
Nathan Lyon used to talk about how he and his team-mates would “headbutt the line”. In South Africa eight years ago, they crossed it completely.
Of course, it is no secret that teams have been seeking to influence the condition of cricket balls for years – through saliva, sweets and other means. “Ball maintenance” to give it a more palatable identity.
But when Bancroft tucked a piece of sandpaper down his trousers, that was clearly going too far. Few teams have cheated so brazenly, and in full public view.
All the claims and counter-claims now just sound like white noise.
The bigger point is that this was a particularly unpleasant team, the like of which we will hopefully never see again. A team that did not play cricket hard and fair – as the Australians like to pride themselves on doing – but, certainly in Warner’s case, more like a gang of thugs in whites.
Someone should take their hundreds and five-wicket hauls and throw them in Brian Clough’s bin. He wouldn't have tolerated their antics for a second.
It was a side that found expression in the so-called “attack dog” Warner, a snarling presence who seemed to revel in sledging and send-offs.
Khawaja, too, is not some kind of whistle-blowing saint. He was part of that team and Warner’s close ally. His claim in his book that racial bias prevented his elevation to the Test captaincy is another contentious contribution to a saga in which nobody seems entirely innocent.
For England, this story is manna from heaven.
The potential impact of all this on next year’s Ashes series hardly needs stating.
Australia are doing a magnificent job of imploding long before they reach these shores.
They cannot shake off the dirt of Sandpapergate – and they surely never will.