The Ashes: England out of tune with their fans and former players
BOYCOTT… “With this sort of batting and bowling they couldn’t win an egg cup, let alone the Ashes urn.”
Botham… “If I was an England supporter and had paid the money to come here, I would be asking the ECB for a refund.”
Butcher… “They’ve been beaten by a team with a stand-in captain, stand-in bowling attack, stand-in opening batter - God help us when they get their first XI back.”
And that’s just from those with surnames starting with the letter “B”. Sir Geoffrey, Lord Botham and Mark Butcher were, of course, simply echoing the mood of a disappointed nation.


“Bazball” – “a load of bull****”, as Sir Geoffrey really did say in his national newspaper column on Monday – has been found wanting thus far in its biggest test of all.
And now we are told that the players were “over-prepared” following the latest defeat; indeed, that they “trained too much” before the second Test in Brisbane.
The irony is that head coach Brendon McCullum was probably right in the sense that five intense training sessions were no doubt a compensatory overreaction to the two-day defeat in the first Test in Perth, and no substitute for the sort of match practice which he and the coaching staff for some reason shun; there is no substitute, surely, for time engaged in doing one’s job.
What McCullum’s comments did betray was a lack of understanding of that national mood.


Given the fierce scrutiny that attended England’s lack of preparation going into the series, which amounted to one warm-up game against their own second string and saw captain Ben Stokes dismiss concerned ex-players as “has-beens”, a comment he subsequently tried to withdraw about as convincingly as a politician defending the breaking of a manifesto pledge, they were naive at best.
It cannot be easy in the heat of an Ashes tour disintegrating at speed to always say the right thing and be pitch-perfect in interviews, but factor in the decision not to send Test players for a pink-ball warm-up in Canberra prior to Brisbane (wicketkeeper Jamie Smith, as has been well-documented, had never previously played with the pink ball prior to a poor individual performance at the Gabba) and McCullum’s remarks were the sort of fuel that an escalating fire could have done without.
The whole “Bazball” messaging, indeed, has started to unravel faster than a hostile witness under cross-examination.
“Run towards the danger” - a McCullum classic - has begun to look less like a determination to play positive, aggressive cricket than the mantra of a madman.
There are some sorts of danger that need to be approached with the utmost caution. Mitchell Starc inviting the drive on the up, for example.
An obvious danger, when a tour proceeds as badly as this (albeit there are still three Tests left), is that perspective is lost amid the justified indignation.
There were valid concerns, for example, about sending players to Canberra given the difference in conditions there and Brisbane, a debate to be had about changing direction or otherwise from pre-arranged plans.
Equally, there are now those angry about England taking a break before the third Test in Adelaide, starting on December 17, for beach-time and golf on the Sunshine Coast in Noosa - a place that sounds suspiciously apt given the 0-2 scoreline.
Ironically, though, given everything that has happened, it might just be the best thing to bring the squad together - certainly, at least, in the absence of any tour game.
Ultimately, as Mark Butcher’s comments suggested, the biggest disappointment is that England have underperformed against an under-strength Australian side. Pat Cummins, Josh Hazlewood and Nathan Lyon have 1,166 Test wickets between them; none were involved at the Gabba.
England have form when it comes to recovering from 2-0 down in the Ashes under Stokes and McCullum, their 2023 revival was, of course, sparked by a stirring win at Headingley before rain on t’other side of t’hill denied them the chance of a 3-2 win.
But this feels different, this feels avoidable, this feels like a big chance wasted up to this point. There are only so many times that you can trot out the line that “there is so much talent in that dressing room” before people start to question if that is the case.
Where to now? Stick with the crew thumped twice by eight wickets, or freshen things up?
That is a difficult one for Stokes and McCullum: the break in Noosa could well be beneficial for those players struggling; equally, there is an argument for shuffling the pack, albeit not too many available cards.
It may be too tall an order to win the Ashes from here but fans and former players want to see fight.
England were not “over-prepared” - that much is clear.
Only results can turn it around now for a team that has lost control of its message.