Barnsley 2 Northampton Town 2: Reds fluff defensive lines once again in front of meagre Oakwell crowd

ON Saturday evening, Conor Hourihane luxuriated in an all too brief spell of calm after his Barnsley side’s excellent victory over Stevenage - and fatefully remarked how things were ‘in a good place.’

Events on a difficult deadline day 48 hours on put paid to that and suddenly, moods darkened again among the club’s fanbase, who were entitled to think just where things were going again.

The dank and bleak February weather at Oakwell on Tuesday night provided a fitting accompaniment in the circumstances.

Those diehards who weren’t lured by a night at home by the fireside - among a very low crowd of 8,806 - needed something.

Barnsley's David McGoldrick makes it 1-1 against Northampton. Picture: Jonathan Gawthorpeplaceholder image
Barnsley's David McGoldrick makes it 1-1 against Northampton. Picture: Jonathan Gawthorpe

It looked being worth it with goals from captain-for-the-night David McGoldrick - a tenth of the campaign - and a strike moments after coming on from Adam Phillips turning it around for Barnsley after Nesta Guinness-Walker tapped lowly Northampton ahead very early.

But the spirited visitors, fighting for their lives and without a league win in 2026, could not be put down and Max Dyche levelled in the final quarter.

Without Davis Keillor-Dunn and with the window doors slammed shut, it truly felt like the start of the rest of the season for Barnsley - now without the talismanic force who had provided a third of their league goals on his own, up to press.

There was a shiver when Northampton scored quickly. Fortunately, it would turn. But fitful defensive habits die hard and Barnsley concede too many goals at Oakwell, simple as that. Whether DKD is here or not.

Barnsley's Adam Phillips scores his side's second. Picture: Jonathan Gawthorpeplaceholder image
Barnsley's Adam Phillips scores his side's second. Picture: Jonathan Gawthorpe

It ended in a third successive draw between these two in Barnsley and the Reds have not beaten Northampton on home soil in seven attempts since 1975.

After conceding a poor goal just three minutes in, the last thing Barnsley needed in the circumstances, the evening had the potential to get a bit febrile from a home perspective with fans understandably irked.

Creditably, Barnsley's response was good and displayed a fair amount of character on a night when players needed to step up without DKD around anymore.

Handed the captain's armband in the absence of the ill Luca Connell, McGoldrick visibly looked determined to make his mark.

He was here, there and everywhere and clearly pumped up; maybe even trying a bit too hard at times.

On one occasion, he did brilliantly well down the right and his low cross just needed a tap in and flashed across goal. But you wanted him in the middle on a night like this.

Thankfully, he was in the right place to level on the half-hour mark - in a more central position - after a clinical free-kick routine from Scott Banks, who posted threat and a trick or two in the first half.

He was at the hub of most of Barnsley's better moments. One spin and swivel was a delight in particular before he curled a shot wide.

Barnsley really should have crowned an impressive response by taking the lead in the run-up to the break. Max Dyche was dispossessed and the recalled Vimal Yoganathan surged towards goal.

Instead of picking out the waiting McGoldrick, he showed a bit of inexperience and went for glory and screwed his shot wide.

There was angst earlier when Northampton took the lead.

Jack Vale found space too easily on the right and cut the ball back to ex-Reds midfielder Cameron McGeehan. His low shot was blocked by Owen Goodman, with Nesta Guinness-Walker gobbling up the rebound from close range.

Cobblers didn't look like a side in lousy form in the first quarter and looked slick, up for it and organised. Cajoled not to feel sorry for themselves after a run of eight league games without a victory, the relegation-haunted certainly weren't. But Barnsley fortunately got their act together after.

Still, Northampton posted the odd warning on the counter and went close to retaking the lead themselves when McGeehan fired a shot just wide.

Barnsley pushed on the restart, with their first decent chance seeing Yoganathan head over under pressure after Cleary manufactured half a yard on the left.

In search of a goal, Hourihane summoned Phillips, recovered from a bout of illness and soon reaped a dividend when he was in the right place to nip in and steer home McGoldrick’s deflected shot from close range.

In a bid to instigate a response, Nolan rang the changes and as with Hourihane, he soon got a rebound.

Replacement Kamarai Swyer headed down Joe Wormleighton’s cross and Dyche stole in to nod home from close range following pressure from the visitors. It was a scruffy concession. Two-all it was.

Barnsley: Goodman; O’Keeffe, O’Connell, Shepherd, Watson (Ogbeta 77) ; Banks, Bland, Yoganathan (Phillips 61), Cleary; Kelly, McGoldrick. Substitutes unused: Flavell, Roberts, De Gevigney, Chirewa, Farrell.

Northampton Town: Fitzsimons; Willis (McCarthy 59), Dyche, Forbes (Eaves 69), Wormleighton, Taylor, Campbell, Guinness-Walker; Hoskins (Swyer 60), McGeehan (Fornah 59); Vale (List 69). Substitutes unused: Burge, Perkins.

Referee: T Parsons (Rochdale)

Attendance: 8,806 (247 Northampton Town fans)

News you can trust since 1754
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice