Barnsley FC player ratings with substitutes taking leading roles but goalkeeper the star

Barnlsey’s best outfield players were their substitutes in Tuesday’s 1-1 draw with Wigan Athletic, but it needed a big performance from Owen Goodman to give them the chance of taking anything.

Owen Goodman – hesitant for the Wigan goal, but his saves kept Barnsley in the game 8

Corey O'Keeffe – an excellent run late on as the Reds pushed for an equaliser 7

Mael de Gevigney – frustrated the crowd at times 6

Eoghan O'Connell – struggled with the pace of Joe Taylor 5

Jack Shepherd – one brainless throw-in in an otherwise good performance 7

Luca Connell – hit the crossbar with a free-kick on an otherwise poor performance from the captain, who was at fault for the opener 5

GOOD MAN: Owen Goodman was in good form for Barnsley (Image: Pete Norton/Getty Images)placeholder image
GOOD MAN: Owen Goodman was in good form for Barnsley (Image: Pete Norton/Getty Images)

Patrick Kelly – his poor pass backwards set an unfortunate tone 6

Reyes Cleary – Barnsley did not get him into the game enough 6

Vimal Yoganathan – a subdued performance in the hole 6

Scott Banks – similar story to Cleary 6

IMPROVEMENT: Adam Phillips (Image: Cameron Howard/Getty Images)placeholder image
IMPROVEMENT: Adam Phillips (Image: Cameron Howard/Getty Images)

David McGoldrick – little to work with, but his long-range effort set up the equaliser 6

Substitutes:

Adam Phillips (for Yoganathan, 52) – his introduction, along with Tom Bradshaw, lifted the performance up a notch 7

Tom Bradshaw (for McGoldrick, 52) – flicked a header over shortly after coming on 7

Charlie Lennon (for Cleary, 71) – forced a save then scored the equaliser showing the get-up-go that had missing for so long 7

Gabriel Ogbeta (for de Gevigney, 71) – another substitute who did well 6

Jonathan Bland (for Kelly, 80) – brought some energy 6

Not used: Watson, Flavell.

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1754
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice