Barnsley player ratings: One nightmare mark and some very low scores against Plymouth Argyle

HERE are the Barnsley player ratings from Easter Monday’s League One home game against Plymouth Argyle at Oakwell.

Goodman: Hesistant at times and won’t reflect on his involvement in Plymouth's first half goal with any fondness. Should have saved the penalty as well. 4

Bland: Restored to the side at right-back. You feel he is happier in midfield. 5

de Gevigney: Made one important first-half block. Kept going, unlike some. 5

Barnsley's Reyes Cleary was recalled to the starting line-up for the home game against Plymouth Argyle. Picture: Jonathan Gawthorpeplaceholder image
Barnsley's Reyes Cleary was recalled to the starting line-up for the home game against Plymouth Argyle. Picture: Jonathan Gawthorpe

O’Connell: Oseni was a real irritant. 5.

Shepherd: Nightmare afternoon. Poor in possession and didn’t cover himself in glory for Argyle’s opener or the second. Stupidity for the penalty as well. 3

Connell: Tried his best to get Reds going. 6

Yoganathan: Not his day. Remains a work in progress. 5

Barnsley's Jonathan Bland returned to the Reds' starting line-up on Easter Monday. Photo: Tony Johnson.placeholder image
Barnsley's Jonathan Bland returned to the Reds' starting line-up on Easter Monday. Photo: Tony Johnson.

Kelly: Quiet in first half, but should have done better with one chance. 5

McGoldrick: Barnsley’s go-to man didn’t have one of his better days. 5

Cleary: The odd flash, but nowhere near his levels earlier this season. Body language wasn’t great. 5

Bradshaw: Battled away, but little impact where it hurts opposition teams. 5

Substitutes: Phillips (Bradshaw HT) 5.

Banks (Bland 67) 5.

Farrell (Yoganathan 78).

Not used: Flavell, M Roberts, Lennon, Watson.

News you can trust since 1754
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice