Hull City player ratings on mixed night for stand-in goalkeeper

Hull City were outclassed but not embarrassed by the club world champions in the FA Cup.

Four-nil was a fair reflection of the gulf between the Championship play-off contenders and Champions League Chelsea, despite a spirited display from a Tigers side without some key players who were rested.

Dillon Phillips – a couple of good saves but particularly poor for the second goal and his distribution severely undermines his authority 5

Paddy McNair – like all the Hull defenders it was hard to be too harsh on him but he had a difficult night 6

John Egan – unable to deal with the pace of Chelsea's forwards 5

Cathal McCarthy – a lively performance from the academy-reared defender 6

Lewie Coyle – kept Alejandro Garnacho reasonably quiet without doing much the other way 6

Regan Slater – provided his usual drive in midfield 7

DEJECTED: Hull City's Liam Millar (right) and Regan Slater after Chelsea score their second goal (image: Mike Egerton/PA Wire)placeholder image
DEJECTED: Hull City's Liam Millar (right) and Regan Slater after Chelsea score their second goal (image: Mike Egerton/PA Wire)

Amir Hadziahmetovic – fighting against the tide in midfield 6

Ryan Giles – forced a good save at a free-kick 7

Yu Hirakawa – struggled to make an impact on the right of a front three 5

Lewis Koumas – hit a post late on 6

SAVE: Dillon Phillips denies Liam Delap but there was more bad than good from the Hull City goalkeeper (image: Mike Egerton/PA Wire)placeholder image
SAVE: Dillon Phillips denies Liam Delap but there was more bad than good from the Hull City goalkeeper (image: Mike Egerton/PA Wire)

Liam Millar – made up for his own mistake in the first half to create a good chance for Koumas, but did not make enough impact 5

Substitutes:

John Lundstram (for Hadziahmetovic, 63) – unable to get on the ball and dictate, which is his game 5

Joe Gelhardt (for Millar, 63) – posed a bit of a threat when he came on 6

Kyle Joseph (for Hirakawa, 76) – flashed a good ball across in stoppage time 6

Cody Drameh (for Coyle, 76) – his appearance was just about getting important minutes on his return from injury 5

Kieran Dowell (for McCarthy, 80) – N/A

Not used: Pandur, Jacob, Famwo, Tinsdale.

News you can trust since 1754
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice