Once more into the Valley of tears: Charlton Athletic 7, Huddersfield Town 6

MANY in the crowd of 12,535 at The Valley in December 1957 had given it up as a bad job. After all, Charlton Athletic were 5-1 down at home to Huddersfield Town in the old Second Division with just 27 minutes of the match remaining.

What’s more, Huddersfield had enjoyed a numerical advantage from as early as the 17th minute, when Charlton captain Derek Ufton dislocated a shoulder and had to go off in the days before substitutes were permitted.

It was cold, it was miserable, it was thin gruel indeed for the patrons of south-east London, some of whom decided to salvage what remained of the last Saturday afternoon before Christmas while they still had the chance.

It was 5-1 – or 1-5 – when Ufton was taken into the operating theatre at Miller General Hospital in nearby Greenwich. As he remembered in an interview a few years before his death in 2021: “When I came back around, the game had long since been over and I asked my dad what had happened in the rest of the game.

The Valley in the 1950s. Photo by Ron Case/Keystone/Getty Images.placeholder image
The Valley in the 1950s. Photo by Ron Case/Keystone/Getty Images.

"He said, ‘I don’t know, I’ll just go and find out.’ So he went away and came back to tell me that we had won 7-6! Nobody would believe him.”

Even now, almost 70 years later, the score of that match still reads like a misprint. The Observer selected it as one of the 10 biggest turnarounds in sporting history, and rated it the greatest ever seen in football.

While Ufton was under full anaesthetic, Johnny Summers, Charlton’s dashing left-winger, who had scored their first goal shortly after half-time, scored four more and created the other two. When the final whistle sounded, the home fans who had kept the faith stormed the pitch and carried Summers and his team-mates off the field in triumph.

What of poor Huddersfield, still the only club to have lost a Football League match after scoring six goals? Ken Taylor, who was in the Huddersfield side that day and who died last Sunday at the age of 91, remembered that it was all too much for Bill Shankly, the then Huddersfield manager.

Johnny Summers, who scored five goals for Charlton Athletic against Huddersfield Town. Photo by Evening Standard/Hulton Archive/Getty Imagesplaceholder image
Johnny Summers, who scored five goals for Charlton Athletic against Huddersfield Town. Photo by Evening Standard/Hulton Archive/Getty Images

In Drawn to Sport, his collaboration with the acclaimed cricket author Stephen Chalke, Taylor – who was also part of the great Yorkshire side that dominated cricket’s County Championship in the 1960s – said the future Liverpool manager took it pretty badly.

“He didn’t speak to anybody for days afterwards,” Taylor said. “We had a good side, but when you played in muddy conditions like that, all sorts of things could happen.”

Happen they did on this astonishing afternoon, one of the most bizarre that the game has seen.

Like Taylor, the stricken Charlton captain Ufton was a dual sportsman, making 149 first-class appearances for Kent as a wicketkeeper/batsman between 1949 and 1962. Prior to his injury, the match at The Valley had started in unremarkable manner, Charlton even missing “three easy scoring chances”, according to one report.

Huddersfield manager Bill Shankly pictured in 1956. Photo by Fox Photos/Getty Images.placeholder image
Huddersfield manager Bill Shankly pictured in 1956. Photo by Fox Photos/Getty Images.

Nor was Ufton’s dislocated shoulder any great surprise. He suffered 20 in his career – “13 times on one shoulder and seven on the other” – and estimated that it cost him 100 appearances “because the manager was afraid to play me in case we were reduced to 10 men”.

Jimmy Trotter, the Charlton manager and a former striker for The Wednesday, as the Sheffield club was then known, therefore knew the risks. Maddeningly for him, it wasn’t even a bad tackle or a fall that had left him without his centre-half.

“It was so silly,” Ufton said. “It was their goal-kick and I was just running alongside the Huddersfield centre-forward, Stan Howard. We bumped into each other and my shoulder came out. Simple as that.”

Huddersfield duly hit the front. Goals from forwards Les Massie and Alex Bain left them 2-0 up at half-time. According to the Huddersfield Daily Examiner, it could have been worse as “Taylor and McGarry, the Town wing-halves, took advantage of the weakness of the opposition”.

Huddersfield's injured forward Denis Law watched the match at The Valley alongside manager Shankly. Photo by George W. Hales/Fox Photos/Getty Imagesplaceholder image
Huddersfield's injured forward Denis Law watched the match at The Valley alongside manager Shankly. Photo by George W. Hales/Fox Photos/Getty Images

Shankly’s message at the break was to keep going for the jugular. A young Denis Law, who watched the match alongside his manager after a thigh injury ruled him out, recalled how “Shanks was full of what a bad side they were and how we were going to rub it in”.

Trotter, meanwhile, settled on a tweak in formation, switching left-winger Summers to centre-forward. Summers's place in the team had been under threat, while his boots – held together by sticking plaster – were falling apart.

He put on a new pair that were not properly broken in. They proved to be as magical as Dorothy’s shoes in The Wizard of Oz. Within two minutes of the restart, Summers had halved the deficit, scoring the first of his five goals – all of them finished with his weaker right foot. Huddersfield hit back with three more goals – another from Bain, a penalty from McGarry and one from midfielder Bob Ledger – to make it 5-1.

With each goal, the home crowd thinned out a little more.

The pitch – peppered by persistent drizzle in the cold air – became increasingly muddy, like a pigsty after feeding time.

It was at this point that Summers illuminated the winter’s afternoon. First, he set up a goal for Johnny “Buck” Ryan – 5-2. Then he knocked in another himself off a post – 5-3. Nine minutes later, Summers completed his hat-trick, hammering past the diving Huddersfield goalkeeper Sandy Kennon – 5-4.

“Sandy was a showman,” Ken Taylor said. “A great lad, but he liked to turn easy saves into slightly more difficult ones by moving to one side and diving at the ball. And that day he kept missing them.”

Summers beat him again in the 81st minute – 5-5. And he wasn’t done yet. Nine minutes from time, with the Huddersfield defence floundering in the mud, Summers sent a deflected shot through Kennon’s outstretched legs – 6-5. “Hats were thrown high in the air,” said one report, “and rattles were rattled as never before. The crowd cheered so loudly that they were heard over three miles away.”

Still it wasn’t finished. With four minutes remaining, Stan Howard bundled home an equaliser – 6-6. According to the Examiner, “everybody, it seemed, was content with the draw”.

Then, in the last minute, Summers fed “Buck” Ryan. Defender Tony Conwell slipped fatally in the mud. “Kennon came out,” said the Examiner. “It was all he could do. Ryan shot. It was not a hard drive, and Kennon’s attempt to divert it merely sent it up into the air. It had not enough velocity to go up over the crossbar, and it fell into the net.” 7-6.

After Charlton’s players were carried from the field, they reappeared in front of the main stand to further acclaim. Summers, dragged away by reporters, beamed: “I’ll keep these boots for the rest of my life. I never dreamed they would bring me five second-half goals. This is the happiest moment of my career. I understand Mr Trotter is going to give me the ball, autographed by the players.”

Trotter said: “I’ve been in soccer nearly 40 years and I’ve never seen a match like this. It gave me a bigger thrill than when Charlton won the Cup in ’47.”

The Daily Express called the match “the most fantastic in soccer history”, while the Examiner offered Christmas spirit, rather than condemnation, to the vanquished visitors. “For Town it will be regarded as their 'most successful failure'... they will be criticised for surrendering a 5-1 lead to 10 men and undoubtedly they made mistakes, but from me there are no recriminations – merely sympathy – for they were desperately unlucky to lose.”

One man who wasn’t there – but should have been – was Kenneth Wolstenholme.

“I was assigned to cover the game between Charlton and Huddersfield,” recalled the legendary commentator. “At the last moment Paul Fox (the producer) changed his mind because he couldn’t see that match being all that exciting. The match which was supposed to be of no interest turned out to be the most thrilling, most amazing, in fact one of the most unbelievable games in the history of the Football League. What a game to miss!”

Nine years later, on the other side of town, Wolstenholme would have his own day to cherish when Bobby Moore and his team-mates lifted the World Cup.

They thought it was all over at The Valley in 1957.

It was.

But then came Johnny Summers.

Charlton Athletic: Duff, Edwards, Townsend, Hewie, Ufton, Kiernan, White, Lucas, Ryan (63, 89), Leary, Summers (47, 64, 73, 78, 81).

Huddersfield Town: Kennon, Conwell, Wilson, Taylor, Connor, McGarry (51 pen), Ledger (62), Howard (86), Bain (35, 49), Massie (27), Simpson.

News you can trust since 1754
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice