Ratings: How Rotherham United's players fared against Everton

Blackman: Little to do inside ninety minutes, apart from a late save to thwart Tosun. 7

Harding: Inhibited start, but found his feet. Blazed over a second-half chance. 7

A MacDonald: Played his part in a defensive display which improved after a dodgy start. In the wars in extra time, but thankfully ok. 7

Ihiekwe: Hoodwinked by the dashing Gordon for the opener and compounded it by making an error soon after. But recovered in stetrling fashion. 7

Wood: Difficult opening, but held it together after that and used all his experience. 7

Olosunde. Went close when he cut inside and unleashed a low drive. Took the game to the hosts and enjoyed a milestone moment when he levelled it up. Excellent. 9

Wiles: Grew into the game like a number of his team-mates at a famous old ground. 8

Barlaser: Went close with a piledriver and became a real influence. 8

Lindsay: Beavered away for the Millers in the middle ground. 7

Crooks: A growing force and asserted himself before making way. Became a real presence. 8

Smith: Spurned a good chance in the first half. Put himself about well and made life uncomfortable for the hosts and helped set up leveller. Set the tone for the response. 7

Substitutes: Vassell (Crooks 67), 6; Jozefzoon (Lindsay 76), 6, Hirst (Smith 77), 6; Clarke (Harding 83), 6; Jones (Olosunde 90), 6.

Not used: Johansson, Vickers, Tilt, Miller.