Rotherham United 0 Bradford City 4: EFL Trophy cruise for watching Michael Duff as Alex Bruce's Millers overdo it at back

COMING off the back of a rough defeat and a long old journey, the last thing that you really need is to be facing a high-flying club from the division above, whose players are seeking to impress a new manager.

That was the situation which Rotherham United found themselves in against Yorkshire rivals Bradford City in this northern group EFL Trophy fixture.

Michael Duff’s Bradford City, strictly speaking. Although the new Bantams’ gaffer’s maiden touchline appearance must wait until Saturday - he was serving a pre-existing one-game ban from his time at Wycombe and watched events unfold from the directors’ box in the main stand at the AESSEAL New York Stadium.

Mark Trueman orchestrated matters from the technical area and the Bradfordian was entitled to be pretty pleased by what he saw, more especially in a powerhouse opening full of intensity and threat. Not unlike Duff-ball from his time at Barnsley. Or Alexander-ball for that matter.

Rotherham United manager Alex Bruce. Picture: Jonathan Gawthorpeplaceholder image
Rotherham United manager Alex Bruce. Picture: Jonathan Gawthorpe

Rotherham, fresh from their abject League Two defeat at Exeter City - which Alex Bruce made no apologies for despite currently possessing a pretty stretched squad - found themselves 2-0 down inside 11 minutes, courtesy of goals for Will Swan and Stephen Humphrys. They struggled to cope, initially.

Swan added his second on 62 minutes and a late penalty from substitute Nick Powell – his third goal in the competition – added a fourth as the visitors cruised into the knock-out stages.

All told, it was a pretty exemplary first day at the office – of sorts – for Duff.

There were differences in levels for fair spells in the first half especially. City were bright, sharp, energetic and confident and while it may have been their supporting cast - all outfield players were changed from the weekend draw at Reading - they had too much for the Millers, although the hosts hardly helped themselves either.

Brace: Bradford City's Will Swan netted a double in the EFL Trophy win at Yorkshire rivals Rotherham United.placeholder image
Brace: Bradford City's Will Swan netted a double in the EFL Trophy win at Yorkshire rivals Rotherham United.

City’s third-minute opener was sloppily conceded by the hosts with Swan nipping it to convert a well-placed downward header following Corey O’Keeffe’s outswinging corner for this third goal of the campaign. A good goal for the Bantams, less so for the Millers. It got worse, unfortunately.

The second was a real gift for City, who handed a first competitive start to Harry Ibbitson at wing-back.

Ted Cann, one of seven changes in the hosts line-up, played the ball to Emmanuel Adeboyega. Under pressure from George Lapslie, the Millers’ defender inexplicably slipped and Humphrys finished, despite Adeboyega’s best efforts to atone on the line.

Humphrys had a chance to add to his tally as did Humphrys, with the Millers’ best moments falling to Aaron Nemane.

His crisp early shot narrowly flew over, while he was the beneficiary of a loose blind pass inside from Corey O’Keeffe, only for Cam Dawson, on his Millers’ return, to show alertness to the danger and block well at his feet.

The Millers had more tempo and conviction at the start of the second half. Their crowd, sensing this is a time for patience, kept with them.

Nemane was threatening at times, as was Jili Buyabu. And then Millers spoiled things by overplaying from the back for a second time.

Cann’s short pass out, from a goal kick, to Douglas, a big defender who looks more of a stopper than a ball-playing centre-back, did him few favours.

It was compounded by loose control under pressure from Swan. The ball broke for Humphrys and after his effort deflected off Adeboyega, the ball found its way to Swan, who tucked away his second of the night.

Home changes arrived. Lively young substitute Kane Richardson, in his first appearance in almost exactly a year, tested Dawson.

Commendanly, the hosts didn’t throw the towel in. Joe Rafferty shot at Dawson, but the ex-Miller pocketed his clean sheet.

Gloss for the visitors arrived when Powell converted from the spot late on after fellow replacement Harrison Duncan brought him down.

Rotherham United: Cann; Rafferty, Douglas, Adegboyega (Hall 74), Ngwenya (Duncan 81); Spence (Austerfield 64), Ashley (Richardson 64); Nemane (Kaleta 64), Fitzgerald, Buyabu, Bradshaw. Substitutes unused: Eyestone, Thornton.

Bradford City: Dawson; Welch, Matthews, Gillesphey; Ibbitson, Morgan, Cartwright, O’Keeffe; Lapslie (Powell 67), Swan (Phillips 74); Humphrys. Substitutes unused: Hadi, Connolly, Pratt, Pointon, Pennington.

Referee: J Robinson.

Attendance: 1,419 (467 Bradford City supporters).

News you can trust since 1754
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice