Rotherham United v Doncaster Rovers player ratings: Substitutes take the plaudits

Doncaster Rovers ended their terrible run of results in Rotherham after a poor first-half display.

Cameron Dawson – will be having nightmares about his mistake 4

Joe Rafferty – beaten too easily by Glenn Middleton for the equaliser 5

Emmanuel Adegboyega – a late call-up when Zak Jules pulled out in the warm-up and did well 7

Jamal Baptiste – had some important moments defensively 7

Reece James – a solid performance from the left-back 6

GAME CHANGER: Glenn Middleton (image: Pete Norton/Getty Images)placeholder image
GAME CHANGER: Glenn Middleton (image: Pete Norton/Getty Images)

Shaun McWilliams – a real threat in the first half 7

Kian Spence – helped his sider win the first-half midfield battle, but not the second 6

Josh Benson – had a good game but unable to last the distance 7

Harry Gray – limited impact 6

EARLY IMPACT: Duncan Watmore (Image: George Wood/Getty Images)placeholder image
EARLY IMPACT: Duncan Watmore (Image: George Wood/Getty Images)

Duncan Watmore – had a very good first half but inevitably faded on his first start in 13 months 7

Sam Nombe – kept his cool for the penalty despite Thimothee Lo-Tutala's best efforts to put him off 7

Substitutes:

Ar'Jany Martha (for McWilliams, HT) – unable to grab hold of the game as his team-mates struggled 6

Dru Yearwood (for Benson, 75) – could not turn the tide 5

Gabriele Biancheri (for Watmore, 75) – little opportunity to show what he could do 5

Brandon Cover (for James, 79) – N/A

Not used: Cann, Agbaire.

Doncaster Rovers (4-1-4-1)

Thimothee Lo-Tutala – his only save was from a Benson free-kick 6

Jamie Sterry – takes credit for Gray's quiet afternoon 7

Neill Byrne – thought he had scored late on but flagged offside 6

Jay McGrath – had an awful start but recovered his composure well 6

Jack Senior – had a hero head bandage after a clash of heads with Harry Clifton 6

Robbie Gotts – like the team, he got better in the second half 7

Luke Molyneux – kept his cool for the winning goal 7

Owen Bailey – dropped deep for a spell to help Gotts out in his usual high-level display 7

Elliot Lee – disappointingly quiet in the first half 5

Hakeeb Adelakun – tried things which did not come off 5

Billy Sharp – saw very little of the ball 5

Substitutes:

Glenn Middleton (for Adelakun, HT) – a surging run set the tone for Doncaster's second half 8

Harry Clifton (for Lee, HT) – another who injected much-needed energy 8

Brandon Hanlan (for Sharp, HT) – scored, but there was more to his game than just that 8

George Broadbent (for Gotts, HT) – kept things secure late on 6

Jordan Gibson (for Molyneux, 87) – N/A

Not used: Pearson, Middleton, Oram.

News you can trust since 1754
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice