Comment: Why Sheffield United could benefit from concentrating on Championship play-offs after third straight defeat

"You can't give up until anything is mathematically impossible and it would be a big concern for me if they have."

That was interim coach Jon Worthington talking about his Huddersfield Town players on Saturday evening, but it could have been the manager of any team on the outer edges of a title race or an automatic promotion battle, mired in the relegation zone or, like the Terriers, feeling like the play-offs are slipping out of reach.

Never giving it in until it is mathematically impossible is a footballing badge of honour, and one Sheffield United's Chris Wilder will certainly be wearing at the moment. But is it such a bad thing?

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Maybe, just maybe, there is a time and a place for it. Maybe it has come at Bramall Lane.

Elite sport is played between the ears as well as on the pitch, and the closer to the sharp end of a competition, the more important it is in sifting the winners from the losers.

It was quite right so much attention paid to Rory McIlroy's sports psychologist Bob Rotella after the Northern Irishman finally ended his 11-year wait to complete the set of golf's Masters on Sunday in Augusta, with golf fan Wilder almost certainly watching from his sofa.

McIlroy's near-misses have become the stuff of legend. In footballing parlance, he had become more "Spursy" than Tottenham Hotspur, finding imaginative ways to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

A double bogey on the first to wipe out his overnight lead looked like being the latest, but in hindsight perhaps the release in expectation helped him drag it back to win a sudden-death play-off.

STUMBLE: Sheffield United manager Chris Wilder (centre) speaks to the players following defeat at Plymouth Argyle (Image: Nick Potts/PA Wire)STUMBLE: Sheffield United manager Chris Wilder (centre) speaks to the players following defeat at Plymouth Argyle (Image: Nick Potts/PA Wire)
STUMBLE: Sheffield United manager Chris Wilder (centre) speaks to the players following defeat at Plymouth Argyle (Image: Nick Potts/PA Wire)

"Never give up on your dreams," McIlroy told daughter Poppy – and the world – as he tried on his new green jacket. As life lessons go, it was a good one, but with caveats.

York City did give up three weeks ago, and it seems to have had a similarly liberating effect on them as the double bogey did for McIlroy.

The Minstermen lost at Braintree Town on March 22 to drop 14 points behind Barnet in the race for the only automatic promotion place into the Football League.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

“Before today I didn’t think (the title race was over) and that was the message to the players," admitted manager Adam Hinshelwood. "I think it’s over now, to be honest."

CONCESSION: York City manager Adam Hinshelwood (Image: Jonathan Gawthorpe)CONCESSION: York City manager Adam Hinshelwood (Image: Jonathan Gawthorpe)
CONCESSION: York City manager Adam Hinshelwood (Image: Jonathan Gawthorpe)

York have won all four games since, scoring 17 goals. Barnet have won one, lost one, drawn one. Now the gap is six points – and three goals' difference – with four games left for each. The Bees are still favourites but the certainty has ebbed.

In April 1992, shortly before Sky invented football, Leeds United followed back-to-back draws with a 4-0 hammering at Manchester City. A point clear with two games in hand, a first English title in 25 years was Manchester United's to lose.

They did.

A weight lifted off their shoulders, a 0-0 draw at Liverpool were the only points the Whites dropped in their last five games.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad
PYSCHOLOGICAL BARRIERS: Golfer Rory McIlroy (Image: Richard Heathcote/Getty Images)PYSCHOLOGICAL BARRIERS: Golfer Rory McIlroy (Image: Richard Heathcote/Getty Images)
PYSCHOLOGICAL BARRIERS: Golfer Rory McIlroy (Image: Richard Heathcote/Getty Images)

Now Leeds and Burnley are the ones with everything to lose in the race for automatic promotion to next season’s Premier League.

In theory, Sheffield United could wipe out the five-point gap to one or more likely the other over the Easter weekend, when they host Cardiff City and travel to Burnley.

This time last week, with one win in six and their vice-captain Pascal Struijk picking up what Whites fans feared then and know now is a season-ending injury, things felt pretty desolate at Elland Road, where a ragged-looking team were stuck outside of the play-off places. Now they are top of the table.

It is not just three straight defeats but the manner of them behind the sense of foreboding now parked at Bramall Lane. Only one goal, Wilder's dig at the away fans at Oxford United and televised handbags in the Home Park tunnel all give the impression of a team that have lost their cool when they need it most.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Add in that Leeds seem to have regained theirs – back-to-back wins steadying them after that six-game wobble – and that Burnley's has never gone away, 29 league games unbeaten.

But even if – if – automatic promotion is over, the season is not.

RELEASE: Gary McAllister's Leeds United lost 4-0 at Manchester City in April 1992RELEASE: Gary McAllister's Leeds United lost 4-0 at Manchester City in April 1992
RELEASE: Gary McAllister's Leeds United lost 4-0 at Manchester City in April 1992

The Blades are in a different situation to Huddersfield, five points adrift of the League One play-offs with four games to play.

Whilst the Terriers have no choice but to shut out realism, follow Worthington's lead and fight to the end, the Blades have an escape route they must be careful not to block off.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

The first leg of the play-off for whoever finishes third in the Championship is in 23 days' time, and the Blades might be well advised reset their minds for that now because if they go into it weighed down by psychological baggage, the best team in the four-team competition will be the first knocked out.

Concentrating on the booby prize will hurt the pride of Wilder – who loves his golfing analogies – and go against everything he believes in.

But it might just be what takes his team back to the Premier League – maybe even automatically.

Comment Guidelines

National World encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.

News you can trust since 1754
Follow us
©National World Publishing Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice