Barnsley FC v Sheffield Wednesday player ratings as defender, creator and goalscorer stand out

Barnsley and Sheffield Wednesday played out an entertaining South Yorkshire derby ultimately decided in its first 15 minutes.

Barnsley showed good spirit after going behind to two early Jamal Lowe goals, bit not enough to avoid a 2-1 defeat.

Barnsley (4-2-3-1)

Cieran Slicker – did not make a save but ended up on the losing side 6

Jubril Okedina – stood off Jamal Lowe for the second goal 5

Sam Gale – worked hard defensively and got forward at one point in the second half 7

Arley Kay – moved into the centre, he did well 6

Ziyad Larkeche – got forward but unable to find the net 7

SPIRIT: Barnsley (Image: George Wood/Getty Images)placeholder image
SPIRIT: Barnsley (Image: George Wood/Getty Images)

Luca Connell – played an important role in central midfield 7

Patrick Kelly – captain for the night, he did not let anyone down 7

Rylan Brownlie – not much impact on the right wing 6

Vimal Yoganathan – cool finish from a man in fine form in front of goal 7

LITTLE SERVICE: Davis Keillor-Dunn (Image: George Wood/Getty Images)placeholder image
LITTLE SERVICE: Davis Keillor-Dunn (Image: George Wood/Getty Images)

Reyes Cleary – made a goal and hinted at his talent 7

Makenzie Kirk – a few loose moments when more composure was needed 5

Substitutes:

Tyrese Noslin (for Yoganathan, 81) – like all the Barnsley subs, it was late for him to have much impact 5

Ben Hamed Toure (for Kirk, 81) – as above 5

Daniel Johnson (for Kelly, 86) – N/A

O'Rian Reid (for Okedina, 86) – N/A

Connor O'Riordan (for Brownlie, 90) – N/A

Unused substitutes: Ravenhill, Alker.

Joe Lumley – made some saves, even if most were not that taxing 7

Yan Valery – more right-back as opposed to wing-back the previous Saturday, he stood off for Barnsley's goal 6

Di'Shon Bernard – held firm defensively 7

Liam Cooper – commanding at centre-back on a night for digging in, he also got an assist 8

Sil Swinkels – did a job in an unfamiliar position 6

Billy Mitchell – worked hard in midfield 7

Jayden Heskey – not a night for him to really shine 6

Jamal Lowe – two composed finishes and he came close to a hat-trick in the second half 8

Barry Bannan – had a hand in both goals and an excellent all-round performance from him 8

Callum Slattery – difficult for him to dominate 6

Davis Keillor-Dunn – no fairytale goal against his former club because the chances were not made for him 6

Substitutes:

Liam Palmer (for Swinkels, 70) – did a steady job seeing the game out 5

Louie Barry (for Mitchell, 70) – important minutes but he did not really shine 5

Jordi Liongola (for J Lowe, 70) – played high up the pitch without much impact 5

Harry Gray (for Bannan, 78) – the liveliest of the substitutes 6

Ricardo Santos (for Bernard, 86) – N/A

Unused substitutes: Morrison, Trueman.

News you can trust since 1754
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice