Sheffield Wednesday player ratings: How did teenager Cole McGhee perform on debut?

Sheffield Wednesday put 2025 to bed with their first clean sheet of the year at Hillsborough.

Pierce Charles – made a couple of saves but not as many as the pattern of the game suggested he should have to, unable to ping any of the trademark brilliant passes he produced on Boxing Day 6

Dominic Iorfa – one almost comedic dribble was his highlight but his rashness was exposed at times defensively 5

Gabriel Otegbayo – good defensively but missed a great chance late on 6

Cole McGhee – the Championship debutant was Wednesday's best player with some excellent defending at the byline 7

Liam Palmer – far from alone, buyt he was loose in his passing and did nothing to stand out defensively 5

Jarvis Thornton – had a second-half shot blocked in an otherwise low-key second outing 6

STAR MAN: Teenager Cole McGhee (Image: Steve Ellis)placeholder image
STAR MAN: Teenager Cole McGhee (Image: Steve Ellis)

Barry Bannan – showed great desire with a first-half run but was not at his best 6

Harry Amass – even his passing was not on point 6

Jamal Lowe – ineffective and substituted 5

Charlie McNeill – Henrik Pedersen noted how he gave the ball away with his first five passes but he recovered from it 6

RECOVERY: Charlie McNeill started poorly but got better (Image: Steve Ellis)placeholder image
RECOVERY: Charlie McNeill started poorly but got better (Image: Steve Ellis)

Bailey Cadamarteri – was feeding off scraps 6

Substitutes:

Svante Ingelsson (for Lowe, 62) – brought something to the party, not least with his long throw-ins 6

Rio Shipston (for Thornton, 79) – little time to make an impact 5

Not used: Cooper, Johnson, Horvath, Grainger, Emery, Moses, Onukwuli.

News you can trust since 1754
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice