'Wasn't a penalty' - Scott Lindsey bemoans decision that cost York City unbeaten start

York boss Scott Lindsey expressed frustration at the officiating as the Minstermen’s unbeaten start to life back in the Football League came to an end at Cheltenham on Tuesday night.

Ollie Pearce handed the visitors a 12th minute lead but Evans struck six minutes later, stabbing home the loose ball after a Charlie McCann penalty had been saved.

It was Evans who handed the home side the lead midway through the second half with a fierce shot from just outside the area only for former Cheltenham striker Jovan Malcolm to level eight minutes later with a fine diving header.

The winner came on 86 minutes as McCann made up for the earlier penalty miss by firing past York keeper Alfie McNally.

York City's unbeaten start is over (Picture: George Wood/Getty Images)placeholder image
York City's unbeaten start is over (Picture: George Wood/Getty Images)

York went into the game on a high after two wins and a draw from their opening three matches and while boss Lindsey praised Cheltenham, he was disappointed by the officiating or two of the goals.

“It was a tough game and I thought they probably competed better than us,” he said. “We probably came second best a lot of the time in terms of the physicality but I felt we still had the lion’s share of possession and the lion’s share of the chances, having 20 shots.

“It wasn’t a penalty for me and I thought there was a foul on (Arthur) Read for their third goal so for me, two of the goals they’ve scored today are down to poor officiating.

“We have to understand that we are at the League Two level where teams are physical. I thought that out of the four games we have played, this was the toughest.

“I did think we looked a little leggy and tired so we need to get them ready for another game on Saturday. We take our medicine and move on.”

News you can trust since 1754
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice