Why Bradford City's Graham Alexander could not say no to Brad Halliday's transfer request

Graham Alexander was sad to see Brad Halliday leave Bradford City on Wednesday, but felt it made no sense to say 'no' when the 30-year-old defender asked to leave.

The Bantams tore up former Middlesbrough, York City and Doncaster Rovers full-back Halliday's contract to allow him to join Scottish Premiership side Dundee on a two-and-a-half-year deal.

He follows Andy Cook, who has joined Grimsby Town on loan until the end of the season and his Valley Parade contract. Halliday's deal was due to expire at the same time.

"One hundred per cent I could say no (to Halliday)," said manager Alexander. "But then I've got an unhappy player and I'm not even playing him.

"I can half-justify sitting in front of a player and saying, 'You're not going anywhere' when he's playing. But when he's not, what's my argument?

"Sometimes I have to be a bit more direct with a younger player because I don't think they've got the experience to make the right decisions.

"We treat our players as men and we understand their whole life so I can't just then ignore it when it suits me or suits the club.

"If you keep a player against his will, he's not really going to buy into what we're doing, is he? I'm not saying that would have been the case with Brad, Cooky or Patto (Alex Pattison, who has joined Walsall for an undisclosed fee) but I want people who want to be here every day."

TOUGH LOVE: Tom McIntyre has gone back to Portsmouth (Image: Lee Parker - CameraSport via Getty Images)placeholder image
TOUGH LOVE: Tom McIntyre has gone back to Portsmouth (Image: Lee Parker - CameraSport via Getty Images)

Alexander praised Halliday's professionalism since asking to leave. After Josh Neufville’s summer arrival he made five League One starts.

“He came to see me probably a week to 10 days before he got back in the team," revealed Alexander. "He said, 'I think I'll be leaving in January. I want to shake your hand when that happens, but I want the team to be flying and whatever I can do to help that along, I'm all in.’

“That's when we moved along with Harrison (Ashby, who has joined on loan from Newcastle United, along with Joe White).

"Brad rang me at home on Monday and said he wanted to see me personally on Tuesday morning and explain what was going on. He wanted to say bye to everyone personally and give everyone a hug. What a guy!

“It was done in the best way possible, probably the best player leaving I've experienced in 12 or 13 years.

“It's sad to see him go because he's a great lad, but he's more than repaid the faith the club showed when they took him after a bad injury.”

Cook did not started or scored in the league after rupturing cruciate knee ligaments on January 1, 2025.

“Everything comes to an end at some point," reflected Alexander.

“From a professional position, for me only, it was an easy decision because of all the factors and my ideas of progressing. From an emotional point of view and what he means to the club and the support, that's when it became really difficult.

“I didn't say, ‘You have to leave,’ I explained what the picture would look like for the next five months. I hope at some point Cooky will think, 'That was the right time to leave.’

"Andy Cook came here five years ago, he leaves the fourth-top-scorer in the club's history, with a (League Two promotion winner's) medal around his neck and the last goal he scored is against his beloved Newcastle United at St James's Park."

The decision to cancel Tom McIntrye's loan from Portsmouth was taken differently.

"I said to him on Friday, I'm going to take the decision now because he came here for gametime and he's one of the best guys I've ever met,” explained Alexander. "I said if I was your agent now or your dad or your brother, I would be saying you have to go out and play football."

He expects others to leave and be replaced.

"I think there'll be one or two (going)," he said. "That's why we're still working on potential incomings. If we thought that was it we would just close the book and crack on.

"If they do, we'll hopefully have a replacement and the best squad we can possibly have on February 2."

News you can trust since 1754
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice