York City ratings: Minstermen marks from first game back as a Football League club

HERE are the York City player ratings from Monday evening’s EFL Cup preliminary round tie against Crawley Town at the LNER Community Stadium.

McNally: Made one important first-half save on his debut. 6

Williams: One great saving tackle early on. 6

Johnson: Steady before giving away a late penalty. 6

York City's Ollie Pearce. Photo: Tony Johnson.placeholder image
York City's Ollie Pearce. Photo: Tony Johnson.

Medley: Surged forward when the opportunity arose. Had York’s best first-half chance and crashed an effort against the bar on the restart. Exposed once or twice in first half. 6

J Hunt: Got into some good positions on right, but delivery found wanting at times. 6

A Hunt: Lively in the press and showed great energy levels. 6

Banks: One or two contributions, in a deeper role without effecting the game in the final third. 6

York City defender Zak Johnson. Photo: Tony Johnson.placeholder image
York City defender Zak Johnson. Photo: Tony Johnson.

Brookes: Tons of effort before running out of gas. 6

Grey: Tenacious - if not always with the right decision on the ball. Got in some good situations and didn’t go away. 7

Pearce: Stationed on the left and York didn’t see the best of him there. 5

Akinyemi: Worked hard on his second debut and linked up play well at times. Missed a big second-half chance. 6

Substitutes: Newby (Brookes 57) 6.

Felix (J Hunt 67) 6.

Olley (Akinyemi 77).

Not used: Sykes-Kenworthy, Fallowfield, Read, Shelton, Farrar, MacArthur.

News you can trust since 1754
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice