Danny Care backs England to conjure 2012 magic with new match-winner ready to emerge

The last time England beat New Zealand at Twickenham, it was the Manu Tuilagi show.

The formidable All Blacks arrived in 2012 protecting a 20-match unbeaten run that stretched back to their World Cup triumph the previous year.

England, by contrast, had won just one of their previous six games and were long odds to knock New Zealand off their perch.

But the All Blacks had never encountered Tuilagi before. As visiting full-back Israel Dagg put it, the powerhouse centre "was absolutely destructive – he was ripping us to shreds".

Tuilagi scored one of England's three tries and played a central role in the two others in a famous 38-21 win, their biggest ever in the fixture and one of New Zealand's heaviest defeats.

For Danny Care, who won 101 caps but only once finished on the winning side against the All Blacks, the memory remains vivid.

"It was a mad game," said the former scrum-half, a late replacement that day.

"Manu Tuilagi was just on another level that day and they literally couldn't tackle him. That was amazing to be a part of and to have him on your team.

Manu Tuilagi celebrates a try during England's win over New Zealand in 2012.  (Photo: Clive Rose/Getty Images)placeholder image
Manu Tuilagi celebrates a try during England's win over New Zealand in 2012. (Photo: Clive Rose/Getty Images)

"I'd already had plenty of games against New Zealand where you'd think it was a successful game if you were within 15 or 20 points of them.

"You won't really get a game like that ever again. I don't think they saw it coming.

"To beat the All Blacks is what you dream of as a kid. You want to face the Haka and beat them."

Sadly for England, wins over New Zealand have been few and far between.

Danny Care gets to grips with Ma'a Nonu. (Photo: Julian Finney/Getty Images)placeholder image
Danny Care gets to grips with Ma'a Nonu. (Photo: Julian Finney/Getty Images)

The Red Rose have beaten the All Blacks just eight times in 46 attempts and only twice since 2003.

Although New Zealand's grip on world rugby has loosened in recent years, their mystique remains.

"When I hear people say they've lost their aura and all that sort of nonsense, it gets me wound up a little bit," added Care.

"They'll never lose that. That All Black shirt is probably the most famous shirt in rugby history.

England have not beaten the All Blacks since their 2019 World Cup semi-final success. (Photo: Hannah Peters/Getty Images)placeholder image
England have not beaten the All Blacks since their 2019 World Cup semi-final success. (Photo: Hannah Peters/Getty Images)

"They'll always be the team everyone wants to beat. It's shifted a little bit in the last few years to South Africa but there's still something about that team and that shirt that brings the best out of players. It's also why it's so hard to beat them."

Ireland and Scotland have already tried and failed this autumn, while England know the challenge all too well.

Steve Borthwick's side suffered a series of narrow defeats to the All Blacks last year but have found a winning formula in 2025, racking up nine straight victories to boost confidence ahead of Saturday's Twickenham showdown.

To truly establish themselves as a major threat to the southern hemisphere powerhouses, however, they must clear a mental hurdle, according to Care.

"I think England are in a really, really good spot," he said.

"Their strength in depth is frightening. They have to now take the next step and challenge the best teams in the world.

England are in good shape ahead of the latest meeting with New Zealand. (Photo: David Rogers/Getty Images)placeholder image
England are in good shape ahead of the latest meeting with New Zealand. (Photo: David Rogers/Getty Images)

"They've done some great work so far but they've got to beat one of these big bosses to unlock the potential to win the Six Nations and ultimately the World Cup in 2027.

"This Saturday isn't a must-win game but it would propel the team forward if we could. You can't underestimate how much belief that would give the squad.

"They believe already but when you play the same rugby against the superpower in world rugby, it gives you incredible confidence."

This time last year, Borthwick was struggling to strike the right balance between style and substance.

England's recent record points to a coach who has learned from a frustrating five-match losing streak.

"I think he's doing a brilliant job," said Care.

"I'm a massive Steve Borthwick fan. He obviously gave me an opportunity to play for England again when I thought that chapter was over. He gave me my 100th cap and some great memories at the World Cup and Six Nations.

"I owe him an awful lot and don't want that to cloud my judgement of him as a coach – but I think he's done an unbelievable job.

"You can't ask for much more of England at the moment, apart from beating one of these superpowers. It's the acid test of where this team is at."

To emerge victorious, the hosts must conjure the magic of 2012.

And Care has backed a new match-winner to rise to the occasion.

"I think England are good enough to beat New Zealand this weekend," said the Leeds native.

"I'll caveat that by saying I've thought that a lot over the years and New Zealand just find a way of hanging in and nicking it at the death. They're the ultimate Test match animals.

"I'm still going to tip England to win 26-22. They would have learnt an awful lot from coming so close last year.

"Hopefully Immanuel Feyi-Waboso can do what Manu did all those years ago. That kid is electric and could cause them problems."

News you can trust since 1754
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice