'Steve Borthwick is not the most charismatic': Flood-gates opening on ex pros giving England coach a kicking

To the long list of former players taking turns to line up and kick England from Murrayfield to Twickenham to Rome these past few weeks, add the name of Toby Flood.

The former Red Rose fly-half has questioned the lack of emotion and passion shown by under-fire Steve Borthwick and his coaching staff in a Six Nations campaign that could go down in infamy as their worst ever.

After chastening defeats to Scotland and Ireland and a historic humbling in Italy, a brow-beaten England face the most daunting task in all of northern hemisphere rugby tonight when they visit the Stade de France to take on Les Bleus.

Six weeks ago this championship-ending 8pm kick-off was expected to be the fitting denouement of the tournament, pitting together two sides with the grand slam on the line. Instead, England are on their knees, looking to avoid their worst championship finish in the Six Nations era, and France are stung having been ambushed by Scotland at Murrayfield last week, but still favourites for the title.

Maro Itoje, the England captain, leads his team off the pitch after their defeat in the Guinness Six Nations 2026 match between Italy and England at Stadio Olimpico (Picture: David Rogers/Getty Images)placeholder image
Maro Itoje, the England captain, leads his team off the pitch after their defeat in the Guinness Six Nations 2026 match between Italy and England at Stadio Olimpico (Picture: David Rogers/Getty Images)

Numerous former internationals have turned on Borthwick’s England and the criticism of recent retirees Courtney Lawes, Ben Youngs and Jonathan Joseph will have stung.

Lawes has said the younger players are “quite sheltered”, questioning their appetite for the fight, while Youngs and Joseph have been unsparing in their criticism of the stats-based, kick-heavy gameplan favoured by Borthwick. England have talked about tuning out the background “noise”, but the volume is currently at an all-time high.

Flood - the former Newcastle Falcons fly-half who was captained by Borthwick in the latter stages of his eight-year career - agrees with the over-reliance on stats but also believes it is in other areas where the leadership is lacking.

“Steve is not the most charismatic of souls,” says Flood.

Steve Borthwick, Head Coach of England, looks on during the England Captain's Run at Stade de France on March 13, 2026 in Paris, France. (Picture: David Rogers/Getty Images)placeholder image
Steve Borthwick, Head Coach of England, looks on during the England Captain's Run at Stade de France on March 13, 2026 in Paris, France. (Picture: David Rogers/Getty Images)

“He's not an inspirational leader in terms of what he says; he's a leader in terms of the architecture he puts around the team. Is he going to give a Churchillian speech before a game? No.

“Take Scotland after their loss to Italy, for example. The players’ reaction seemed to be based around protecting Gregor Townsend when England came up for the Calcutta Cup, and Scotland have done some remarkable things since.

“I’m not sure you get that from the players toward Steve because of his personality. He doesn't scratch the itch of connecting with people on a personal level; he finds that very hard to do. You can see why, when relationships are strained and you haven't created a tight bond with the team, those cracks become larger due to a lack of social connection.”

Flood saw first-hand in the defeat at Murrayfield five weeks ago, which was the first jolt to England’s progress after a stellar 2025, this lack of inspiration from Borthwick and his lieutenants, which includes Kevin Sinfield and the former Rotherham Titans boss Lee Blackett.

Andy Farrell can still win the 2026 title with Ireland and is being linked to England. (Picture: Paul Faith / AFP via Getty Images)placeholder image
Andy Farrell can still win the 2026 title with Ireland and is being linked to England. (Picture: Paul Faith / AFP via Getty Images)

“I stood not too far from the coaches' box at Murrayfield, and there seemed to be very little emotion coming out of it,” said Flood, when speaking to The Yorkshire Post via BettingLounge. “They appeared to be letting the players make the majority of decisions. That is generally what you want, as the players have the feel, knowledge, and cadence of the game on the pitch.

“As a coach, you have to trust your players to make the right calls. It is only once or twice in a game where you can come over the top and override a decision.”

And Flood believes that is cascading down the stands and into the men in white.

“There seems to be a lack of confidence around the side and a lack of willingness to take risks,” he offered.

“There’s a noticeable lack of appetite - likely not from the players, but from the coaching staff - to move the ball around and put teams under pressure with ball in hand.

“We all know Steve Borthwick is very statistically driven: do X, get Y. Rugby can work like that at the international level where the game is more controlled. However, the boys who play week in, week out in the Premiership achieve far more and push the envelope, exposing themselves to risk for their clubs.

“England’s 12-game winning run was based predominantly at home where "Fortress Twickenham" mentality surely played a part.”

If, as expected after their sudden slump, England lose again, does Borthwick deserve to continue in the role with a World Cup now 18 months away?

“The RFU didn’t give them a convincing vote of confidence did they,” asks Flood. “But with the Bill Sweeneys of this world, you’ve got to hedge your bets. I think they will stay. It would be hard to change now, and the counter-argument is: who replaces them?

“I’m not sure there are that many suitable candidates banging down the door. Andy Farrell would be the obvious choice, but rumours are that he has signed for Saracens after the World Cup.

“If you do change, it takes a huge amount of time to turn the ship around.

"The question is can Borthwick fix this. To do so, England need to start pushing and pressuring the opposition with ball in hand, not being so driven by statistics and kicking the ball away.”

News you can trust since 1754
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice