Gig review: Bonnie ‘Prince’ Billy at Albert Hall, Manchester


Will Oldham turns selections drawn from his vast back catalogue into an off-kilter yet richly expressive, harmony vocal-laden folk-country-jazz hybrid.
Some way into tonight’s show, the artist formerly (and formally) known as Will Oldham stops to acknowledge drummer Alex Neilson. “Alex is from Leeds,” Oldham (who proceeds to pledge allegiance to The Mekons) quips. “He’s always happy to come to Manchester, apart from the days that include the letter ‘a’.”
Tonight’s show would be worth a far longer journey than the hop over the Pennines that separates West Yorkshire from the grand confines of the Albert Hall.
The by turns eerily skeletal and propulsively driving arrangements unleashed by Oldham and the three-piece band (accompanied by keyboardist John Ashton for some tunes, and for roughly half of the set, the soaring backing vocals of veteran Bonnie ‘Prince’ Billy collaborator Dawn McCarthy, whose strong support set culminates with an unsettling take on the traditional ballad House Carpenter) turn selections drawn from all corners of Oldham’s vast back catalogue into an off-kilter yet richly expressive, harmony vocal-laden folk-country-jazz hybrid.
Dating back to the mid-90s when Oldham still traded as Palace Brothers, the opener New Partner finds guitarist Thomas Deakin join Jacob Duncan’s saxophone on clarinet while Neilson’s soft rummaging around his kit provides more of a suggestion of drums than an actual beat. Like It Or Not putters to life with Deakin’s counterintuitively angular flutter of discordant guitar chords. With Oldham now emphasising his impressively powerful singing and assertively rhythmic nylon-stringed strumming by perching on one leg in the style of a heron, and with a perfectly timed police siren cutting through the audience’s reverential hush, Boise, Idaho finds the show fully hits its stride.
Perhaps due to the presence of Oldham’s vocal foil from the album, the set is heavy on 2006’s McCarthy-assisted The Letting Go. The album’s hauntedly beautiful folk-rock stylings suit the band perfectly. Then The Letting Go blooms into a wildly strutting, flute-fuelled psych-folk hoedown – with increasingly animated Oldham hopping, skipping and stomping and pacing back and forth whilst unleashing wordless off-mic exhortations – before easing into a spectral coda. The gradually intensifying, atmospherically charged crawl of the saxophone and trumpet-led Strange Form of Life provides another jaw-droppingly intense, hypnotically escalating highlight.
Full of good cheer, Oldham is clearly enjoying himself and his superbly expressive band immensely, and there are moments of quirky and warm camaraderie to leaven the more emotionally charged moments. Merch guy Oscar is invited on stage to join a communal take on Jimmy Webb’s evergreen Highwayman (delivered in the style of country supergroup The Highwaymen, with everyone on the now crammed stage taking a verse): he turns out to have a great voice. A take on Don Everly’s Omaha feels almost ripely theatrical in its drama next to starkly to-the-bone performances like Lay and Love.
Oldham’s ceaseless rate of productivity and occasionally confounding choices (the mannered but ultimately compelling classic Nashville songwriting manoeuvres of 2025’s The Purple Bird, say) can make it easy to overlook the scale, quality and often considerable emotional pull of his output. Tonight’s frequently mesmerising 100-minute performance (which finishes with a standing ovation from the enthusiastic audience) provides a powerful reminder of Oldham’s considerable talents.