Fiscal devolution won’t work because England has been balkanised - Yorkshire Post Letters
I write in response to your leading article about fiscal devolution (The YP, July 19) and comments attributed by The YP to Lisa Nandy on the same subject.
You make the case for devolution (backed by significant distributed funding) to regions. I agree - provided the regions are large enough.
Advertisement
Hide AdAdvertisement
Hide AdThe UK is only big enough for a handful of regions - Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland already exist (smallish in population terms); but England is being steadily balkanised into combined authorities and various mayoral fiefs and this is the problem - they are too diverse and too small, and the boundaries cause too much friction.
There's only room for about four English regions - North, Midlands, South-East (including London) and South-West. These would be big enough to have proper elected governments which would take over most powers from Whitehall and which would allocate funding across their whole territory.
The current mishmash is just a classic example of Whitehall divide-and-rule. Until proper regions are established I am glad to hear funding will be retained in the centre.