Four star review of Dust at Edinburgh Fringe


Stage: Dust Pleasance Courtyard, Edinburgh Fringe Yvette Huddleston 4/5
Writer-director Charlaina Thompson’s outstanding debut play was inspired by the real-life tragedy which took place at Lofthouse Colliery near Wakefield in 1973 when seven miners lost their lives after accidentally breaching a flooded abandoned, and uncharted, 19th century mineshaft.
The play takes the form of a solo show telling the story of one man’s life – a Yorkshire miner – across several decades. Craig Mc Ardle’s powerful, often very moving, performance is an absolute tour de force. As he takes us through the man’s life story – his work as a boilermaker, then down the pit, a stint as a soldier on national service and bouts as an amateur boxer – he lives and breathes every one of the many characters he portrays, switching between them adeptly and making each one totally believable. The energy and attack of the protagonist as a young man – all pent-up anger and cocky self-assurance – is contrasted with the vulnerability of the older man, now near the end of his life, in hospital desperately trying to hold on to fragments of memory through the haze of dementia.
There is tenderness too with an affecting love story at the heart of the narrative, as well as a tangible sense of the profound bonds of comradeship among the miners. The terrible injustice of what happened at Lofthouse is powerfully conveyed, as is the brutal reality for those men risking their lives on a daily basis in order to extract coal from the seams miles underground.


Both the writer and the performer have close ties to the mining communities of west Yorkshire – Thompson grew up in a mining family near Doncaster and McArdle’s own grandfather worked at Lofthouse colliery alongside the men who perished in the disaster. That personal connection to the material ensures that every word, every emotion, every story, every flash of dry Northern humour is entirely authentic. It is a production that is admirable on every level and in so many different ways – as a piece of theatre, as a social document and, above all, as a heartfelt tribute to the miners of west Yorkshire and their families.
To August 30.
