'Really disappointing': Yorkshire Water being downgraded to one-star status by Environment Agency

Yorkshire Water is to be downgraded to a rare ‘one-star’ rating by the Environment Agency for its poor environmental performance, The Yorkshire Post can reveal.

CEO Nicola Shaw said there were several mitigating factors involved, including delays to work to protect Pudsey Beck which are now not due to be completed until 2028.

But she added: “Yorkshire Water’s performance is not good enough, and it's going to take us some time to turn that around. I think we will be a one-star company this year.”

She confirmed the position ahead of details being published in the company’s latest accounts next week which will state it anticipates being given the downgraded rating when the EA publishes it in October. The rating is based on performance in the 2025 calendar year.

Yorkshire Water chief executive Nicola Shaw pictured at the company's Killingbeck site near Harrogate. Picture: Bruce Rollinsonplaceholder image
Yorkshire Water chief executive Nicola Shaw pictured at the company's Killingbeck site near Harrogate. Picture: Bruce Rollinson

Ms Shaw said she has not taken a bonus due in part to the expected rating, but confirmed she had received a pay rise and had also taken another £660,000 payment from the firm’s parent company Kelda Holdings. That is on top of a base salary and pension contribution increase raising her Yorkshire Water remuneration by £43,000 from £689,000 to £732,000.

The Environment Agency rated Yorkshire Water as a two-star company last year following 151 pollution incidents in 2024. It got the rating alongside eight others also deemed to require improvement. Only Thames Water received the lowest one-star rating.

Ms Shaw said the situation highlights why the firm’s ongoing £8.3bn infrastructure investment programme is vital.

“I said last year we wanted to improve. Therefore it is really disappointing to see the reduction this year.

"There are three reasons for it. The first two relate to serious and total numbers of pollutants. Since the beginning of last year, I’ve been saying this is a challenge for us.

"It is partly our asset base that needs lots of work and that’s why the investment programme we have is so important.

“The last one relates to a construction project that went wrong back in 2021 and we won’t be able to solve that one until 2028.

"Because of the few projects we have delivered relatively, it makes a big impact this year. Hopefully it won’t in the future. I look forward to us improving. That’s what we need to do for the people of Yorkshire.”

She added: “We had not understood the extent to which our assets were really struggling and in particular our treatment works in rural locations. We have more than 300 across the region that needed to be reviewed.

"At the same time, standards required for them were going up, so we made lots of investment in those last year."

She said that if it wasn’t for the delays at Pudsey Beck, the lower rating would not be getting imposed.

“If it hadn't been for that one, even with the situation on pollution, we would have still been a two-star company.

"We want to get better, and I know this isn't good enough. I also know we can't turn around infrastructure business overnight the issue in relation to Pudsey Beck is a long-term issue.

“The ambition is always not to pollute and and particularly not to have serious pollution. Second is to deliver on the promises that we made in our plan to 2030, and that's a huge amount of investment.”

The Environment Agency did not wish to comment.

News you can trust since 1754
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice