'Yorkshire Water 2.0 is on the way': CEO Nicola Shaw assembling new future for firm as Swedish investors arrive

Nicola Shaw says she is determined to lead ‘Yorkshire Water 2.0’ into the future with support of new Swedish investors despite heavy criticism of her tenure. Chris Burn reports.

Customer bills substantially up, environmental performance down and a huge controversy about secret offshore payments - on the face of it, Nicola Shaw’s tenure as Yorkshire Water chief executive does not currently appear to be a great success.

Both her and her company’s reputations risk going further underwater when next week’s financial accounts confirm it is set to be downgraded to a rare ‘one-star’ rating from the Environment Agency due to its poor pollution record.

But swim below the surface and a much more nuanced picture emerges of a CEO who is resolving long-running financial complications, securing new investors and delivering a gigantic investment programme which should transform Yorkshire’s water quality and infrastructure for generations to come.

Yorkshire Water chief executive Nicola Shaw pictured at the company's Killingbeck site near Harrogate. Picture: Bruce Rollinsonplaceholder image
Yorkshire Water chief executive Nicola Shaw pictured at the company's Killingbeck site near Harrogate. Picture: Bruce Rollinson

It begs the unexpected question - does the record of one of the nation’s most-criticised chief executives deserve to be seen in a new light?

****************

As Nicola Shaw settles down to be interviewed in the tiny kitchen building at a remote countryside sewage treatment works, The Yorkshire Post’s photographer suggests she may want to move her chair slightly away from its barred windows to avoid any unfortunate impression she is being pictured in prison.

“There’s plenty of people who’d like to see me there,” she smiles. It’s a self-deprecating joke but one that’s not far from the truth given the storm of criticism that has come her way during her four years as Yorkshire Water chief executive – particularly after it was revealed she had received previously-secret annual payments of £660,000 from the organisation’s Jersey-based parent company on top of her already-generous salary.

Yorkshire Water chief executive Nicola Shaw pictured at the company's Killingbeck site near Harrogate. Picture: Bruce Rollinsonplaceholder image
Yorkshire Water chief executive Nicola Shaw pictured at the company's Killingbeck site near Harrogate. Picture: Bruce Rollinson

There was widespread anger and MPs accused Shaw of “taking us for fools”, with Harrogate and Knaresborough’s Tom Gordon calling on her to quit, saying “the stench of sewage clings… to the bosses of Yorkshire Water” over the payment.

Leading water campaigner Fergal Sharkey suggested earlier this year that instead of ‘slap on the wrist’ fines for pollution incidents, water company bosses should actually be jailed.

Shaw is meeting The Yorkshire Post ahead of the imminent publication of Yorkshire Water’s latest annual results which will show she has received another £660,000 from Kelda and also reveal the company expects to be downgraded to a one-star rating from the Environment Agency.

But she also wants to discuss the company’s enormous ongoing investment programme across Yorkshire which it has perhaps struggled to fully communicate to the public in the midst of regular controversies.

Ilkley is among the areas to already benefit from investment.placeholder image
Ilkley is among the areas to already benefit from investment.

The Killinghall wastewater treatment works near Harrogate has been chosen for our meeting after recently being subject to a £19m project to improve water quality in the nearby River Nidd – in part through the addition of specially-grown bed of rushes to capture elements of sewage which could harm wildlife.

The scheme is of undoubted importance but is just a tiny piece in the jigsaw of Yorkshire Water’s ongoing efforts to transform its ageing infrastructure and tackle its well-documented pollution problems.

An £8.3bn programme of work – secured after Shaw and Yorkshire Water convinced regulators of its need – is being conducted up until 2030, with dozens more sites like Killinghall being subject to schemes designed to reduce phosphorus entering waterways.

Hundreds of miles of water mains are being replaced, hundreds of millions are being spent on cutting storm overflows and plans are in place to improve bathing water quality in Scarborough, Robin Hood’s Bay and Bridlington. A £75m project has been completed in Ilkley to increase storage capacity to protect the River Wharfe.

"The storage capacity at Ilkley is now enormous and that allows us to hold storm water that comes down off the hills,” Shaw says.

Yorkshire Water has taken on an additional 1,200 staff in the past year to help deliver the programme – a 25 per cent increase to its workforce. The investment is coming at a substantial cost to customers; bills are increasing by average of 41 per cent over five years.

Many customers have been left unimpressed given the company’s poor reputation in recent years, the controversy around executive pay and an ownership structure controlled by foreign investors. Yorkshire Water has recently secured a new investor in Swedish private equity giant EQT taking a 42 per cent stake in parent company Kelda Holdings. It has joined Singaporean wealth fund GIC and Australia’s TCorp, an investment partner to the New South Wales public sector, as co-owners.

The deal was something of a coup for Shaw, who has previously described the EQT’s backing as a “strong vote of confidence in our plan to improve performance and the progress we have made so far”.

Shaw came to Yorkshire Water in May 2022 with an impressive CV including a CBE for services to transport. She previously led High Speed 1, authored a Government-commission report on Network Rail and was executive director at National Grid. She was immediately thrust into a challenging situation as regulator Ofwat investigated £940m of intercompany loans amidst concerns about Yorkshire Water’s financial resilience.

The case was closed after an agreement was made that the loans would be repaid by March 2027 and a further £100m would be invested by shareholders to improve the company’s position. “The chair Vanda Murray and I managed with the Ofwat chair and chief executive to bring the board and the shareholders with us on an agreement about the way that was going to be resolved,” she says. “That’s a billion pounds that shareholders collectively have put into the business without the likelihood of return. Getting that agreed wasn’t easy.”

EQT’s new involvement in the company included a commitment to ‘contributing’ towards the outstanding £600m repayment alongside other shareholders. Shaw says getting “binding commitments” on the intercompany loan repayments is a major step forward for the business, as was getting regulatory agreement to deliver its huge infrastructure programme.

She says she was also pleased that Yorkshire Water’s representations to the recent Cunliffe review into the future of the water industry appear to have made a difference – particularly in regard to his recommendations for a single integrated water regulator to replace the multiple organisations currently overseeing different issues, as well as the creation of new regional water authorities to come up with local investment plans.

“The Cunliffe review gives the industry a chance. If we hadn’t had that, I think it would be very difficult to continue to motivate myself and the organisation to keep going. I certainly think we wouldn’t have seen more investment from a new investor. I think that has been a really important building block for protecting the level of investment that is being made, and I think we have to go again because we need to get better. So I’m really pleased now we have the staff, we have the investment funding.

“We’re the only company that was promoting the concept of the integrated water regulator, we were also promoting regional engagement – both are central to his recommendations. We’re also the only company that got the money it asked for in the 2024 price review so I feel positive about some of the steps and the interventions we’ve made. Now we will prove it to people in Yorkshire who are trusting us to do it.”

But it is fair to say any big picture successes during Shaw’s tenure have often been overshadowed with a series of seemingly unending controversies regarding its performance.

Last year, the firm was ordered to pay £40m to address its “serious failures” over wastewater and sewage discharges. It has also faced a series of court cases involving six-figure fines for water pollution - including an £865,000 fine for pumping out millions of litres of chlorinated water into a dike in Barnsley over a month in 2017, killing hundreds of fish in the process.

The company’s issues do not just relate to pollution. Shaw reveals next week’s results will show it is one of the worst-rated water companies for customer service. “Our customer service ranking leaves us 12th in the industry, so we obviously need to improve. We’re planning to do that in the short term and longer term. The short-term is to make sure we treat customers with a lot more respect, make sure we help them with something that’s wrong by giving them dedicated people to talk to them and a second voice to talk to.”

Shaw admits the job has been in a different category to her previous roles. “The level of public scrutiny is definitely higher. Intellectually, I knew that would be the case but practically it is very different. It’s not just me, we’ve had nasty things said to members of our staff. I think that the general frustration in the country sometimes gets taken out on them, and that’s pretty unpleasant.”

The arrival of new investors has led to a changing of the guard on the company’s board with chair Vanda Murray and six directors due to depart. When Shaw is asked if she sees herself having a long-term future with Yorkshire Water given that context and the inevitable fresh scrutiny that comes with new owners, she replies: “I think the investors are committed to the plan we have, and so my job is to look at that and that should keep them confident in us.”

She says the arrival of EQT should send an important signal to customers as they await the improvements. “With EQT and GIC and TCorp’s ongoing support, it means that the business is fired to go again. Yorkshire Water 2.0 is going to come. The future is bright – we are getting better and we will continue to get better. It is going to be a long process but you will see improvements.”

She won’t win over all her critics any time soon but delivering on that promise after years of putting the foundations in place would put a different reflection on Shaw’s tenure.

News you can trust since 1754
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice