Farming leaders brand Treasury 'arrogant' and say their 'blood was boiling' after meeting with ministers

Farming leaders have hit out at the Treasury as “arrogant” and said they left a meeting with ministers over the Government’s changes to inheritance tax with “boiling blood”.

Exchequer Secretary James Murray and Farming Minister Daniel Zeichner spoke to representatives from agricultural groups including the National Farmers’ Union, the Tenant Farmers Association and the Country Land and Business Association in Westminster yesterday.

Yet this was labelled by George Dunn, TFA chief executive, as “one of the most unproductive meetings” he has had during his 28 years in the role.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Rachel Reeves has still not met with the leaders to explain the policy, despite multiple requests and protests, and yesterday they said this showed the Chancellor’s “arrogance”.

NFU President Tom Bradshaw said Ms Reeves should “look us in the eyes and tell us that she’s right”.

In the Budget, the Chancellor announced proposals to introduce a 20 per cent inheritance tax rate on agricultural land and businesses worth more than £1m, essentially scrapping an exemption which meant no tax was paid to pass down family farms.

The plans continue to face intense opposition from the sector, which says cash-poor, asset-rich farmers will be forced to sell their land and investment will stall.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad
Farmers and their tractors have been protesting in Westminster, London over the changes to inheritance tax (IHT) rules in the budget which introduced new taxes on farms worth more than £1 millionFarmers and their tractors have been protesting in Westminster, London over the changes to inheritance tax (IHT) rules in the budget which introduced new taxes on farms worth more than £1 million
Farmers and their tractors have been protesting in Westminster, London over the changes to inheritance tax (IHT) rules in the budget which introduced new taxes on farms worth more than £1 million

NFU President Tom Bradshaw has even spoken of fears that elderly and vulnerable farmers, who do not have time for succession planning, are considering taking their own lives.

Yet he said, following the meeting, that the Government believes it is being “generous in the exemptions” it is giving farmers.

“They don’t care about the human impact, they don’t care about the intergenerational impact,” he said.

“They don’t care about the impact on tenant farmers and the geopolitical situation that the world faces today.”

Hide Ad
Hide Ad
A petition signed by more than 270,000 members of the public has been handed in to 10 Downing Street by NFU President Tom Bradshaw and NFU Cymru President Aled Jones, on behalf of the four UK farming unions, urging government to ditch its devastating family farm tax.A petition signed by more than 270,000 members of the public has been handed in to 10 Downing Street by NFU President Tom Bradshaw and NFU Cymru President Aled Jones, on behalf of the four UK farming unions, urging government to ditch its devastating family farm tax.
A petition signed by more than 270,000 members of the public has been handed in to 10 Downing Street by NFU President Tom Bradshaw and NFU Cymru President Aled Jones, on behalf of the four UK farming unions, urging government to ditch its devastating family farm tax.

Mr Bradshaw said the Government rebuffed their proposed suggestion for a “clawback” mechanism, which would ensure farms face tax charges only when assets are sold.

The groups believe this could raise a similar figure to the current inheritance tax changes, which the Office for Budget Responsibility said would bring in just £500m to the Exchequer over a three-year period.

But Mr Bradshaw says this was dismissed, adding: “The door is shut from the Treasury.

“The reaction from our members is going to be one of fury, one of real anger, one of desperation that we’ve seen over recent months and it’s what we all feel here.”

Hide Ad
Hide Ad
President of the Country Land and Business Association (CLA), Victoria Vyvyan.President of the Country Land and Business Association (CLA), Victoria Vyvyan.
President of the Country Land and Business Association (CLA), Victoria Vyvyan.

Victoria Vyvyan, CLA president, said: “I looked around the room and thought, ‘I’m not sure that there is anybody in this room who really understood when Tom was talking about what a balance sheet looks like’.

“They were just adamant and deaf to what we were trying to say, and I think we all came out slightly with boiling blood about it,” she said.

Mr Dunn, the TFA chief executive, said this was “one of the most unproductive meetings” he has had during his 28 years in the role.

English farms drop by almost a quarter over last two decades

Sir Ed Davey has warned that “farms are on the brink” as new figures show the number of farm holdings has dropped by almost a quarter since 2005.

House of Commons Library data, commissioned by the Liberal Democrats, shows a worrying decline in the number of farms across England.

The latest figures reveal that in the 18 years since 2005 there has been a drop of more than 30,000 farm holdings - a reduction of 22.7 per cent.

The number of farms in almost every crop and livestock category has decreased, but in particular dairy farms have been affected, with the total number of farms cut in half.

“British farmers are the backbone of the economy, yet successive governments have done nothing but neglect them,” Sir Ed, the Lib Dem leader, said on a visit to dairy farmers in Norfolk.

“Farmers look after our countryside and feed the nation, and without them we would be worse off.

“Under the Conservatives’ watch, farmers struggled with botched trade deals and rocketing energy bills.

“Unfortunately, the current Government seems content on maintaining the Conservatives’ appalling track record on farming.

“The family farm tax may be the final nail in the coffin for many farmers.”

“They were clearly unprepared and unwilling and arrogant enough to say: ‘We’ve done all of the thinking. We don’t think we have to ask any more questions. Job done. We’re not making any changes’.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

“So the battle continues because we do think they’ve got this severely wrong,” he said.

A government spokesperson said: “We regularly meet representatives of the farming industry to listen to their views, but strongly believe this is a fair and balanced approach which helps fix the public services we all rely on.

“Our reforms to Agricultural and Business Property Relief will mean three quarters of estates will continue to pay no inheritance tax at all, while the remaining quarter will pay half the inheritance tax that most people pay, and payments can be spread over 10 years, interest-free.

“We are also investing £5 billion into farming over the next two years, the largest amount for sustainable food production in our country’s history, and are going further with reforms to boost profits for farmers by backing British produce and reforming planning rules on farms to support food production."

Comment Guidelines

National World encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.

News you can trust since 1754
Follow us
©National World Publishing Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice