Government said there is 'insufficient evidence' of additional costs for rural areas, North Yorkshire Council claims
The Government told North Yorkshire Council that there was “insufficient evidence” to show that providing services in rural areas was more costly, a senior officer has claimed.
The local authority has published its Budget proposal for the next financial year, which is set to be voted on by councillors on 13 February.
This outlines how Labour’s changes to the local government funding formula - to focus solely on deprivation instead of the extra expenses of rurality - will cut £33m off North Yorkshire Council’s annual budget.
House of Commons Library research shows that urban areas like Luton, Coventry and Birmingham have had huge rises in funding, while rural areas have largely missed out.
Former prime minister Rishi Sunak, the MP for Richmond and Northallerton, wrote to the Government on behalf of North Yorkshire MPs on some of the “anomalies” in reforms.
This was despite Angela Rayner pledging to account for the extra costs of “remoteness” to rural local authorities, such as “travel time” for services like bin collection, transport and homecare visits, ahead of the changes.
North Yorkshire Council says these cuts come on top of the scrapping of the rural services grant, which provided £14m a year.
It means it is highly likely that council tax will get hiked by the maximum 4.99 per cent each year for the next three years, and savings will have to be made to services.
North Yorkshire leader Coun Carl Les said: “You would hope that the number of MPs Labour have representing rural constituencies they have a better understanding of, not only the costs of rurality, but actually how the rural economy works and how councils work in rural areas.
“But it does appear as if they don't have that level of understanding. It's hard to argue against deprivation as a motivation for interventions, but the point that we have made consistently is that you shouldn't put deprivation against rurality.
“They're both indicators on the same spectrum, and both should be dealt with accordingly.
“I worry that the view from Westminster and Whitehall is that rural areas are nice, leafy places where everything's happy and they don't understand the problems that we've got - not least of which is that our productivity is more costly.”
North Yorkshire Council’s Corporate Director of Resources Gary Fielding said the local authority was invited to provide evidence that “suggested that they were inclined to measure the rurality”.
“We provided evidence that showed that it costs, on average, £5more per hour to deliver home care in a super rural area than it is in an urban area.
“We got told that there was insufficient evidence. So I would have to say I suspect this is policy driven and not evidence driven.
“It is self-evident. If you think about waste collection, what evidence do you need to demonstrate that going from one house to another in a rural hamlet or village is inevitably going to cost more than it does in an urban area.”
The Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government has been contacted for comment.
At the time of the funding announcement, Local Government Minister Alison McGovern said: “By fixing the link between funding and deprivation, we're giving local areas the tools to create opportunities, support families, and rebuild the services that hold communities together.
“This is how we deliver a fairer Britain where everyone has the chance to succeed."
