Inheritance tax raised as 'single biggest issue to farming viability' in Batters Review

The inheritance tax changes were not part of the scope of Baroness Minette Batters’ farm profitability review, although she said it was raised as the “single biggest issue” to farming viability going forward.

The former National Farmers’ Union President said the UK needs a “radical re-think of how we value food and farming”, and called for a “new deal for profitable farming” that recognises the true cost of producing food and delivering for the environment.

Baroness Batters, who led the NFU for seven years and is now a cross-bench peer, was commissioned by the Labour Government earlier this year to conduct an independent farm profitability review.

She completed the report in October and handed it into the Department for the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Defra) on Halloween, however it was only published yesterday on Parliament’s final day before recess.

This has led to accusations that the Government had tried to hide the review, with Shadow Farming Minister Robbie Moore accusing Environment Secretary Emma Reynolds of keeping it “buried in her department until well after the Budget”.

NFU President Minette Batters.placeholder image
NFU President Minette Batters.

Ms Reynolds said she was “proud” that Labour commissioned Baroness Batters for the review, and added that it was “a lot more than they [the Conservatives] did in 14 long years”.

But the scope did not include the changes to inheritance tax, which are set to apply to farm businesses worth more than £1m.

Baroness Batters said: “It has been made clear in my terms of reference that it is not for me to offer proposals to the Government on IHT (inheritance tax). However, I could not write this report without reference to it.”

She said that “nearly all the responses to this review have cited inheritance tax as the single biggest issue regarding farming viability that they face”.

The former NFU boss explained that “the farming sector is bewildered and frightened of what might lie ahead” and said she had “great sympathy with their concerns”.

Shadow Farming Minister Robbie Moore. Credit: James Hardisty/Yorkshire Postplaceholder image
Shadow Farming Minister Robbie Moore. Credit: James Hardisty/Yorkshire Post | James Hardisty/Yorkshire Post

Mr Moore added: “You almost couldn’t make it up. The government commission a review on the biggest barriers to farm profitability.

“And they explicitly prevent the author of the review from making any recommendations on the family farm tax - which the report itself goes on to identify as ‘the single biggest issue regarding farming viability’ that farmers face.”

Baroness Batters said the farming industry had also faced a sharp rise in costs and increasingly extreme weather, with severe drought this year.

Input costs will be 30 per cent higher in 2026 than they were in 2020, while the £2.4bn farming budget for England has been almost the same since 2007, even as farmers and growers are asked to do more to comply with environmental legislation, with less funding and no certainty, she said.

She added: “Farmers don’t want handouts from the state, they want nothing more than to run thriving, profitable farming businesses, by earning a fair return for what they produce”.

NFU President Tom Bradshaw with Defra Secretary Emma Reynolds at the Back British Farming Day reception in Westminster.placeholder image
NFU President Tom Bradshaw with Defra Secretary Emma Reynolds at the Back British Farming Day reception in Westminster.

Baroness Batters said a new deal for farming needed to be developed between Government and industry, with a long-term plan that increases demand for British produce, boosts farming incomes, productivity and resilience, makes supply chains fair, and values nature, wildlife and water quality.

She said she had always been clear that there was no silver bullet to farm profitability, and outlines 57 recommendations in her report.

These include simplifying the sustainable farming incentive (SFI), so farmers not in the scheme can access it, focusing on options that make producers resilient and provide for upland and hill farmers, and only supporting “active farmers” from the farming budget.

Ms Reynolds said Defra would respond in detail to each recommendation in the new year, however regarding Baroness Batters’ call for greater collaboration she yesterday launched a new Farming and Food Partnership Board to bring together leaders from across the agricultural sector.

She said: “When farming thrives, the whole country benefits. British farmers are central to our food security, our rural economy and the stewardship of our countryside.

“Baroness Batters’ Review underlines the need for government, farming and the food industry to work much more closely together. That is exactly what the new Farming and Food Partnership Board will do.”

News you can trust since 1754
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice