Labour denies 'attempting to hide' Batters Review into farming profitability

Labour has denied it is “attempting to hide” Baroness Minette Batters’ review into farm profitability, with the substantial report due to be released this week just hours before Parliament’s Christmas recess.

In April, the former National Farmers’ Union president was asked by the Department for the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs to make recommendations on tackling the deep-rooted problems in agriculture.

She submitted her review to the Government on 31 October, yet Farming Minister Angela Eagle only confirmed yesterday that it would be published this week.

Baroness Batters herself has already expressed her frustration at the delay. She wrote on LinkedIn recently: “I’m more frustrated than anyone that the Farm Profitability Review hasn’t been published.

“But I’m going to hold my end of the bargain, because to be honest there’s too much at stake.”

She added that she thought the delay was “100 per cent cock up” as opposed to “conspiracy”.

As the House of Commons goes into recess on Friday, Baroness Batters’ report will have to be published today or tomorrow - the last Parliamentary days available this year.

At the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Efra) Committee yesterday, Bridlington and the Wolds MP Charlie Dewhirst asked Ms Eagle: “Why is it being snuck out on the last day before Christmas?”

Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer visiting Dame Minette Batters' farm, when she was NFU President. Credit: Gettyplaceholder image
Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer visiting Dame Minette Batters' farm, when she was NFU President. Credit: Getty | Getty Images

“We have to try to get the sequencing of all government announcements right and I don’t think getting it out before Christmas, on whatever day, is an attempt to hide it,” Ms Eagle retorted.

“It is a substantial report, the Secretary of State [Emma Reynolds] is very enthusiastic about the recommendations in it, of which there are many.

“We will be doing our best to give an initial response. I don’t accept at all that we are sneaking it out.”

As Mr Dewhirst, a former pig farmer, was grilling Ms Eagle, the farming community once again took over Westminster in protest.

Tractors spent hours driving up and down Whitehall and around Parliament Square beeping their horns loudly, while some farmers considered dumping manure in protest.

The protest yesterday coincided with the second reading of the Government’s Finance Bill in the House of Commons, which confirms the so-called family farm tax.

NFU President Minette Battersplaceholder image
NFU President Minette Batters

This will see farmers have to pay a half-rate of inheritance tax on assets valued at more than £1m under agricultural (APR) and business property relief (BPR).

Previously these businesses were exempt to allow farms to be handed down to the next generation.

The farming community has said this will destroy family farms, claiming high-asset low-cash farmers will be forced to sell land to pay their tax bills.

One of the protestors said: “It lets MPs know we are still here, still fighting, and not giving up, and it keeps IHT, APR and BPR firmly on the agenda before the Christmas recess.”

At the Efra Committee, Mr Dewhirst told the Farming Minister: “I can only plead that you listen to the farming community, the wider agricultural economy and the family businesses that are in there [on inheritance tax].

Farmers protesting in Westminster. Credit: Stefan Rousseau/PA Wireplaceholder image
Farmers protesting in Westminster. Credit: Stefan Rousseau/PA Wire | Stefan Rousseau/PA Wire

“It is very, very serious, there is a huge impact, there are people committing suicide and we have to change that.”

Baroness Batters has made minimal comments on her report ahead of its publication, however some analysis of the impact of the inheritance tax reforms is expected to be included.

It could put Defra on a collision course with the Treasury, which concocted the policy, and No11 officials continue to insist that minimal farms will be affected.

“Inheritance tax is the tip of the iceberg,” Baroness Batters said, “we need a fundamental reset to deliver the change needed if we want the average small family farm to survive.

“My recommendations give two years maximum to get it done.

“And it all starts with setting out the importance of valuing farming.

“Second homes don’t clear the roads of snow in winter or put out wild fires in the summer.”

Ms Eagle told the Efra Committee that “the fact that the Batters Review ought to be looked at cross party, we may be able to get ourselves into a situation where there’s broad agreement across Parliament about the direction”.

“We’ve got to get some resilience in the system, but we’ve also got to get to the stage where we can take advantage of some of the new trade deals which are being done,” she added.

“That’s also an important part of how we might be able to increase the business opportunities for farming more generally.”

News you can trust since 1754
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice