'Mistakes were made' in abrupt closure of SFI, new Environment Secretary admits

“Mistakes were made” by the Government with the abrupt closure of the Sustainable Farming Incentive (SFI) scheme, the new Environment Secretary has admitted.

Emma Reynolds, who was appointed to the Cabinet in September, pledged to “improve the communication” and said reforming the SFI was “top of our inbox”.

Ms Reynolds made the admission yesterday in her first appearance in front of the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Committee, a cross-party group of MPs which scrutinises her department (Defra).

She was asked what she has been advocating for from the Chancellor in the run up to the Budget on 26 November.

While Ms Reynold said she was not “going to give a running commentary on my discussions with colleagues”, the Secretary of State added: “We recognise that there were mistakes made earlier this year.”

She later made clear that she was talking about the swift closure of the SFI, which Country Land and Business Association deputy president Gavin Lane said at the time had “broken” trust with farmers.

New Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Emma Reynolds. Credit: James Manning/PA Wireplaceholder image
New Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Emma Reynolds. Credit: James Manning/PA Wire | James Manning/PA Wire

The SFI pays farmers in England for “public goods” such as insecticide-free farming, wildflower strips and managing ponds and hedgerows, but closed it without warning last week.

In March, Defra abruptly closed it to new applicants, saying it had allocated its £1bn budget for the year.

Many farmers were in the process of applying when the SFI closed, meaning they faced a cliff edge until the new scheme is available in around spring 2026.

Ms Reynolds pledged that she was “getting under the bonnet of what happened there” and said Defra “has also learned lessons from it”.

Efra Committee chair Alistair Carmichael asked the Environment Secretary: “Is it just a reflection of the capacity in Defra that you keep coming to things later than you should do?”

Ms Reynolds admitted: “We absolutely need to get to things earlier and to improve the communication, and I know what farmers want is predictability, certainty and an ability to plan.”

She said she told National Farmers’ Union President Tom Bradshaw on her first day in the job that sorting this out is “top of our inbox”.

“I know how important it is to get the SFI right,” she added.

Sarah Bool, one of the MPs on the Efra Committee, told the Secretary of State that it is important you “have learnt some lessons as it has been a pretty distressing year or more for farmers”.

On the “positive side”, Ms Reynolds said that half of farmland was now being supported by Defra schemes, with 39,000 farms in the SFI.

The Environment Secretary also confirmed she had Dame Minette Batters’ review into farm profitability, and said it would be published before Christmas.

She told the committee that “backing British farming and the food industry” was one of her four main priorities, alongside cleaning up waterways, restoring nature and the EU reset.

Ms Reynolds said that the former NFU president’s work was “critical to this”.

“I absolutely want to see a more profitable farming sector,” she said.

“We want to ensure agriculture is contributing to growth, supporting food security, but obviously supporting our environmental objectives.”

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1754
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice