Sustainable Farming Incentive: farmers hit out at new cap on environmental scheme payments
Farming groups have criticised the new Sustainable Farming Incentive for bringing in a cap on payments, saying it is “limiting the ambitions of those that can do the most for nature”.
Environment (Defra) Secretary Emma Reynolds announced her reforms for a “simpler, fairer and more stable” SFI at the National Farmers’ Union conference in Birmingham yesterday.
She said the scheme should not be “a choice between food and nature, but a system where both can thrive”.
The SFI pays farmers in England for “public goods” such as insecticide-free farming, wildflower strips and managing ponds and hedgerows.
In March 2025, Defra abruptly closed it to new applicants, saying it had allocated its £1bn budget for the year.
Many farmers were in the process of applying when the SFI closed, meaning they faced a cliff edge until the new scheme this year.
On top of this, the Government has been pursuing its controversial inheritance tax policy for agricultural business, despite making a partial U-turn.
Ms Reynolds told the conference: “I know that for many of you in this room, uncertainty in recent years has been damaging. Not just financially, but in terms of trust.”
The Environment Secretary pledged “clarity and stability” and said “there will be no more sudden unexpected closures”.

Small farms of up to 50 hectares will be able to apply to the new SFI from June, with larger farms in September.
While Country Land and Business Association President Gavin Lane praised Defra for listening “to the CLA and industry to adapt the SFI scheme”, he warned about an £100,000 cap on payments.
He said: “Introducing a cap on payments has risks - limiting the ambitions of those that can do the most for nature.
“This is counterproductive when the government has legally binding environmental targets and some may have no choice but to intensify production.
“Many farm businesses are facing some of the bleakest profitability conditions in a generation.
“The Basic Payment Scheme is virtually gone and SFI is an essential income stream to build business resilience and support food production.
“We will continue to work closely with Defra to ensure the scheme is as accessible and flexible as possible.”
NFU Vice President Rachel Hallos, who runs a beef and sheep farm in Ripponden, told The Yorkshire Post that she would have preferred a cap per hectare, but added: “We have always campaigned for fairness with SFI, that means everybody being included.
“It doesn’t matter what size your farm is, if you can deliver environmental good you should be rewarded for it.”

Defra said that some 97 per cent of farms would not be affected by the new £100,000 cap, and said this will help ensure funding reaches more small and medium-sized farms.
Previously, a quarter of all SFI cash was going to just 4 per cent of farms. The number of actions included in the scheme will be slimmed down from 102 to 71 to remove lower value-for-money options.
NFU President Tom Bradshaw also urged Defra to provide some sort of continuity arrangement for the 10,000 farmers that have SFI agreements ending this year. He said that not putting in place a rollover scheme would be “unthinkable”.
Ms Reynolds said the “intent was there” although the department was still working through it “operationally”.
Five-year activities will now last three years to make the scheme more accessible, in particular for tenant farmers, Defra said.
Payments for several moorland grazing options will increase and be cut for the most popular options including providing winter bird food crops, to encourage landowners to choose a wider range of actions.
The Environment Secretary also announced £50m for a “farming equipment and technology fund” to help farmers invest in tech such as seed-planting robots and pesticide spreaders that reduce chemical use.
