Fears historic North Yorkshire village's church bells could fall silent due to government VAT scheme cancellation
Fears have emerged that a North Yorkshire village’s historic church bells could fall silent due to the government’s decision to cancel a VAT scheme.
More than £150,000 has already been raised towards the replacement of the bells at the Church of St James the Great in Melsonby, near Richmond.
But the government’s decision to cancel the Listed Places of Worship Grant Scheme, which would have meant the VAT could be claimed back on the work, has left the village with a £40,000 shortfall.
Andrew Wilson, a member of the Melsonby Bells Project Group, which has led the fundraising drive, said: “To our dismay, we have just been advised that for the first time the scheme is oversubscribed and being closed, to be replaced with another scheme, details of which will not be released until April 2026.


“There is a genuine concern that if these ancient bells are not replaced in the next 12 months, they will fall silent forever.”
The tower currently contains four bells, with the earliest bell cast in 1370.
The group has been offered six bells from a redundant church in Leeds and aims to install them in the tower, along with two new bells, on a new frame.
Villagers say the existing bells are very difficult to ring, and it is hoped the new ring of eight bells will make it easier to retain and attract ringers.
The group has written to Richmond and Northallerton MP Rishi Sunak asking for his help.
Members are also working on new fundraising ideas to meet the shortfall.
A spokesperson for the Department for Culture, Media and Sport confirmed that the Listed Places of Worship Grant Scheme was now closed for applications.
A spokesperson added: “The scheme was extended for 2025/26 with funding of £23m. The 2025/26 Scheme has been scheduled to close on 31 March 2026, or once the £23m budget has been reached, whichever is earlier.
“The recently announced £92m Places of Worship Renewal Fund is designed to support churches with capital grants for repairs. More information will be announced in due course.”
The government said its evaluation of the Listed Places of Worship Grant scheme showed that 80 per cent of respondents would still have carried out their work without the VAT rebate.
“The Places of Worship Renewal Fund will be designed so that more targeted funding gets to the areas and communities that need it the most, the spokesperson added.
The church dates back to 1115 is on the Camino Way Ingles, a route taken by pilgrims to Santiago de Compostela, in northern Spain, which is reputed to be the burial place of St James the Great.
Anyone willing to help with the fundraising can contact the group by email at [email protected]
