Government 'open-minded' to review 'fracking' in North Yorkshire if new evidence comes to light
The Government is “very open-minded” to reviewing whether the controversial method of gas extraction being proposed in North Yorkshire should be part of the fracking ban if new evidence comes to light.
Scarborough and Whitby MP Alison Hume is “campaigning hard for the Government to extend the moratorium on fracking to include ‘proppant squeeze’ so that we close this loophole and ban fracking for good”.
Europa Oil & Gas is seeking to install a 38m high gas drilling rig on land in Burniston, near Scarborough, as part of its “proppant squeeze” project.
If plans are approved by North Yorkshire Council, the initial scheme would test whether gas could be extracted on a commercially viable basis and, if further approvals were granted, extraction could take place for “about 20 years”.
Campaigners in Scarborough and the wider coast have been protesting against the plans, while Friends of the Earth says it has a legal opinion which shows this should count as fracking.
At the Labour Party Conference, Energy Secretary Ed Miliband announced he would permanently ban fracking, a method of extracting oil and gas from shale rock, by pumping liquids deep underground at high pressures to release the gas trapped inside.
The Department of Energy Security and Net Zero previously told The Yorkshire Post that proppant squeezing would not be included in the moratorium.


However, this week Energy Minister Michael Shanks said he was “very happy to continue to review new evidence as it comes forward” regarding the methods being used in Burniston.
In a debate in Parliament, he said: “This is clearly a complex issue. I understand that there are real concerns from communities about any of these kinds of projects.
“Although the evidence base is important for us to make decisions here, I do not discount for a second the concerns that communities have.
“I want to hear those concerns from across the country. I remain very open-minded, as does the Secretary of State [Mr Miliband], to new evidence coming forward to look at this definition.
“But for obvious reasons, it is important that the Government make policy decisions based on evidence that can stand up to scrutiny if ever challenged in court.”
This comes after the Friends of the Earth (FotE) campaign group said it had obtained legal advice from Estelle Dehon KC, one of the UK’s leading environmental barristers, that shows the proppant squeeze method qualifies as fracking under planning policy.
It says this should influence North Yorkshire Council’s impending planning decision.


FotE senior lawyer, Katie de Kauwe, said: “This fossil fuel proposal shines a spotlight on the glaring loophole in the existing fracking moratorium. The government must close it as a matter of urgency.
“Fracking is deeply unpopular with local communities. It is absolutely essential that both the planning authority and the public know exactly what type of development this is, so that it doesn’t sneak in through the back door.”
Ms Hume added: “Proppant squeeze is fracking in all but name. I welcome the Government’s commitment to outlawing higher-volume fracking, however it must go further and close the loophole that enables oil and gas companies to frack at lower volumes.
“Our community in Burniston are clear in our opposition to Europa’s fracking plans. I will continue to campaign locally and in Parliament for a comprehensive ban on fracking.”
Will Holland, CEO of Europa, said: “I’m disappointed that Alison Hume MP continues to oppose our plans, despite our having actively engaged with her and indeed welcomed her to the prospective drilling site to explain our plans and answer her questions.
“It’s a shame that she would prefer to import gas, at not only a much higher cost to the exchequer but also a much higher cost to the environment given the significantly greater emissions associated with imported oil and gas.”
