'What is the point in Ofwat?': regulator says off-shore payment to Yorkshire Water boss does not flout bonus ban
Campaigners have slammed Ofwat after the water regulator found that the undisclosed off-shore payment of £660,000 to Yorkshire Water boss Nicola Shaw did not flout the Government’s bonus ban rule.
Ms Shaw was paid a total of £1.3m over the 2023-24 and 2024-25 financial years from Kelda Holdings, Yorkshire Water’s Jersey-registered parent company, on top of her £700,000 annual salary.
These fees were not published directly in Yorkshire Water’s annual report and executive pay does not have to be declared in Jersey.
Kelda Holdings - part owned by the Singapore government and various investment funds - is the parent company of UK-based Kelda Group, which then sits above Yorkshire Water in the complex ownership chain.
These payments took Ms Shaw’s overall remuneration over the last two years to above £3m despite the ongoing hosepipe ban, the increase in bills and the significant rise in serious pollution incidents.
Ofwat assessed the £660,000 payment in the 2024-25 financial year, as the Government banned Yorkshire Water executives from taking bonuses for that period due to the poor pollution record.
However, it has now said that “these payments do not fit the definition of PRP (Performance-related executive pay Prohibition Rule) provided in the Water Industry Act 1991 and are therefore not in scope of the rule”.
The water regulator said the under-fire firm should show “greater transparency on executive remuneration” going forward, and added that it is consulting on changing company reporting requirements in the wake of the scandal.
However, campaigners have hit out at Ofwat for failing to take action.
Hilary Plews, from Save our Swale campaign, said: "What is the point of Ofwat if, as an official regulator, it cannot stop Yorkshire Water blatantly getting round the rules by paying its CEO, Nicola Shaw, £1.3m from an off-shore parent company whilst pretending this isn’t a replacement for the bonus Nicola Shaw is not supposed to get because of Yorkshire Water’s appalling pollution record?”
The Green Party’s Coun Andy Brown, ward councillor for the Aire Valley in North Yorkshire, called on Ms Shaw to resign, saying the payment “may be legal but it is immoral and unjustifiable”.


He added: “If Yorkshire Water and its chief executive think that it is acceptable to put up customers' bills whilst making payments that show utter disregard for the feelings of their customers then they are not fit to manage a public service.”
Harrogate and Knaresborough MP Tom Gordon told The Yorkshire Post that the lack of action “exposes the regulator as completely powerless and unfit to protect the public interest”.
He said: “It underscores the urgent need for Ofwat to be replaced by a genuinely independent, tough regulator – one that can hold companies to account, close loopholes for good, and protect both the public and our environment from exploitation for private profit. The Government is dragging its feet.
“Until that happens, shameless executives like Nicola Shaw will continue lining their pockets while our rivers, seas and communities pay the price.”
Yorkshire Water has refused to say whether Ms Shaw will continue to get the £660,000 payments, for which she has no set hours or time commitments for.
However it has pledged to publish full details of any fees paid by Kelda Holdings in future, and align its reporting practices with that of a FTSE 100 company.
A spokesperson said: “Following Ofwat’s review into disclosures regarding remuneration across Yorkshire Water and Kelda Group, the regulator has confirmed that the arrangements are compliant with legislation on performance related pay.
“We remain fully committed to being open and transparent about executive pay. Our focus remains on improving performance and delivering better outcomes for customers, communities and the environment.
“Under Nicola’s leadership and shareholder engagement, investors have provided £500m of new equity to Yorkshire Water, with further investment expected before March 2027.
“Over the next five years we will invest £8.3bn -- around £3.2m every day -- to improve service, reduce pollution and modernise Yorkshire’s water network.”
