'The wrong place' - Plans for 600 homes on edge of Yorkshire market town refused
A petition organiser has spoken of her delight as a plan for 600 homes in Yarm was roundly rejected by councillors.
Taylor Wimpey’s controversial £133m outline scheme for up to 600 homes near Green Lane, Yarm was refused at a packed meeting of Stockton Council’s planning committee on Wednesday afternoon (Mar 4).
Deputy council leader Councillor Paul Rowling said of the proposal, which drew almost 600 objections: “There has to be a time where we actually say no.”
Yvonne Wallace, a Yarm town councillor who set up a petition with over 3,200 signatures opposing housing developments in Yarm because of the plan, said the market town’s residents were appalled, asking: “Is it a case of profit before community?”


She raised the impact on roads, overload and congestion, saying: “We will have another 1,000 cars plus coming on to Green Lane. If this goes ahead, it will be chaos.
“Developers are in it for the money, but all of you are elected to represent local constituents. Don’t let the people of Yarm down with this application,” she said to applause.
Chartered surveyor Michael Brazell spoke of the historic setting and character of Yarm High Street, saying: “Are we really going to swamp and trash such an important heritage asset? The application must be refused.”
Margaret Campion called for facts and figures to be checked, saying: “It isn’t a NIMBY protest, this. It is people who have genuine concerns. We have to live with the consequences of the decision that is made today.”
Pat Tillston said: “You try coming home after 3.30pm. The roads are chockablock. You cannot move in Yarm.”
Christine Mundy raised a “clear and obvious red flag” from Northern Powergrid, which said the area had “limited capacity to support additional homes without upgrades”, saying: “Are we seriously considering a recommendation for approval on 600 dwellings have no guarantees of electricity supply? An approval today is surely putting the cart before the horse.”
Richard Finch said “common sense needs to prevail”, saying “infrastructure cannot support this capacity”, with roads “totally unsuitable for the present traffic, never mind the additional traffic envisaged”, medical practices at capacity and schools near-full.
Taylor Wimpey claimed the plan would bring £85m into the economy and more than 200 jobs. ELG Planning director Steven Longstaff, representing the developer, said the plan was much needed at a time of acute housing crisis, with up to 120 affordable homes.
He said councillors could reduce waiting lists and prevent homelessness, suggesting if they did not approve the plan “you are effectively choosing to perpetuate that shortage”. He said the plan would bring “substantial and material benefits” including green areas, enhanced bus services, cycle connections, and money for the Crathorne junction, education, medical and sports facilities.
Stockton Council’s planning officers recommended approval of the plan. Planning services manager Simon Grundy said it was considered a sustainable site with local facilities, a pub and schools within walking distance.
He said the weight of public objection was “not a relevant factor” and a full council vote weeks ago to move Ms Wallace’s petition forward “carries no weight”. Highways engineer Martin Parker said they did not did not consider traffic impacts to be severe, journey time increases were “not anywhere near” unacceptable levels and “my hands are tied”.
But no amount of traffic assessments or “robust” computer modelling could convince residents or councillors who witnessed the everyday reality that the plan would not create a problem. Officers found the housing, social and economic benefits of the scheme outweighed the harm – however councillors found the opposite.
Debating the plan, numerous councillors said they could not support the plan. Coun Norma Stephenson said her main problem was road safety and traffic capacity, while Coun Rowling said: “It’s already pretty horrific. I think there’s got to be a point where we say as a planning committee, enough is enough.
“It’s bad enough as it is. I just can’t support anything that would make that even worse than it already is.”
Yarm councillor Andrew Sherris said the traffic reports conflicted and figures did not stack up, describing suggestions of zero queueing as “absolutely pie in the sky”. Coun Sylvia Walmsley said: “It’s absolutely ridiculous to say 600 houses will not have an effect on traffic. There’s no capacity, there’s no electricity supply there. It’s in totally the wrong place.”
Coun Tony Riordan said: “We’ve got capacity issues, infrastructure issues, highways issues, electricity supply issues. The whole application and presentation to committee has been rushed. It’s a complete and utter mess.
“It’s not going to get off the ground because the Crathorne interchange hasn’t been upgraded and opened to the public. There’s no infrastructure here, it’s gone, it’s on its knees.”
Coun Lynn Hall said the Crathorne interchange would take years to achieve: “Yet the local roads will take the strain… Anybody who has experienced the Yarm crawl cannot predict how long their journey will take.” She also referred to the protection of wildlife and woodland, saying the site would be “an incursion into the open countryside”.
Councillors voted 13-1 to reject the plan. Afterwards Ms Wallace said: “I’m absolutely delighted with the decision. I’m really pleased we’ve had the backing of the planning committee. It’s been the right decision.”
Asked about the prospect of an appeal from the developer, she said: “We’ll face that when it comes. I think we’ve got strong reasons why it shouldn’t go through, we’ll just keep on fighting.”