Don’t let North Yorkshire become elective dictatorship – Paul Andrews

DEMOCRACY is in retreat all over the world – from Hong Kong to Afghanistan. Even the USA has seen an outgoing president challenge the democratic process.

The reorganisation of local government in North Yorkshire should be seen in this context. The UK has no written constitution. We have become an elective dictatorship where the Government can do what it likes without any real constitutional checks.

In the 1980s, the Thatcher government tried to make local government more democratic. The rule was established that every decision-making committee had to be “politically balanced”. In other words, every political group on a council had to be represented proportionately on all decision-making committees.

What will be the impact of the North Yorkshire local government reorganisation on resorts like Scarborough?What will be the impact of the North Yorkshire local government reorganisation on resorts like Scarborough?
What will be the impact of the North Yorkshire local government reorganisation on resorts like Scarborough?
Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Tony Blair changed all this. His government allowed councils to appoint “executives” from a single political party to run the authority. These are sometimes called “cabinets”, but the word “politburo” best describes them.

In authorities with politburos, the councillors not on the politburo are marginalised and virtually powerless. North Yorkshire has a politburo of just 10 exclusively Conservative members for Britain’s largest county. This is not democratic.

So, for a rural county like North Yorkshire, where the opposition parties are slowly gaining ground at district council level, the Government has seen fit to abolish the districts so as to permanently embed its political control of the county.

This has been a thinly disguised top-down process. Bids for unitary status were invited and North Yorkshire County Council (NYCC) applied. The county’s districts put in a counter bid for an east/west split. The status quo was not even considered.

Skipton is one of the many market towns that will come under the auspices of North Yorkshire's super-council.Skipton is one of the many market towns that will come under the auspices of North Yorkshire's super-council.
Skipton is one of the many market towns that will come under the auspices of North Yorkshire's super-council.
Hide Ad
Hide Ad

The criteria for the decision were financial savings, credible geography and popular support. There was a brief consultation but no popular vote. So, public support for either option could not be properly assessed.

The backers of both options produced inflated savings estimates. Like all dictators, the Government’s argument is that autocratic control is more efficient than democracy. George Orwell’s 1984 nightmare has arrived.

As regards geography, it is difficult to see how Britain’s biggest county could have a single identity, particularly when the economies of districts like Craven are more closely connected to cities like Bradford, while Ryedale, York, Scarborough and Selby are more closely connected to Leeds along the A64 corridor.

The part of Housing Secretary Robert Jenrick’s decision letter approving the single county option contains just three paragraphs.

Harrogate will come under the auspices of North Yorkshire's new unitary authority.Harrogate will come under the auspices of North Yorkshire's new unitary authority.
Harrogate will come under the auspices of North Yorkshire's new unitary authority.
Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Yet last year the Government was asked about the size of new unitary authorities. The answer, given by Simon Clarke MP, then a junior minister, referred to a floor of 300,000 to 400,000 residents.

Now York has a population of less than 200,000 and North Yorkshire has a population of 600,000. The decision letter reads that the “population of the new council is just over the range of population size”. It is outrageous that towns with long histories, like Harrogate or Scarborough, will no longer be able to run their local services. Their valuable assets will be administered by a distant authority in Northallerton or simply sold.

We are told this is progress. In fact this reorganisation is a backwards step. It embeds the politburo system established by Tony Blair, and leaves local decisions with officials instead of democratically elected local councillors.

Before the 1974 reorganisation, planning was done by county councils through area committees. The shake-up changed this to allow elected district councillors to make decisions for their own districts. This allowed far more debate and local public participation. Now we are going back to the old county area committee system – or worse.

malton will come under the new North Yorkshire County Council.malton will come under the new North Yorkshire County Council.
malton will come under the new North Yorkshire County Council.
Hide Ad
Hide Ad

This is important as planning battles which we have had in the past on, for example, Ryedale’s superstore saga and the fracking debate, would have been far more difficult to win if NYCC had been in complete control of local planning – regardless of the merits of the debate.

We are now told to accept this flawed decision. The Conservatives don’t want a public debate. So they raise the dalek-like war cry: “Resistance is futile: you will be exterminated!”

This cannot be accepted. History is full of examples of right triumphing over overwhelming odds – both nationally and locally. Democracy is under challenge. As America’s founding father Thomas Jefferson said, the price of freedom is eternal vigilance.

There needs to be a legal challenge. We need a campaign to save democracy in our country – particularly local democracy. We need somebody with charisma to lead this campaign. Who will it be?

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Paul Andrews is an Independent councillor on Ryedale District Council and former mayor of Malton.

Support The Yorkshire Post and become a subscriber today. Your subscription will help us to continue to bring quality news to the people of Yorkshire. In return, you’ll see fewer ads on site, get free access to our app and receive exclusive members-only offers. Click here to subscribe.

Comment Guidelines

National World encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.