If the Government wants to get young people into jobs then it needs to look into how recruitment operates - Jayne Dowle

When it comes to young people finding jobs, this government is deluding itself yet again.

The Prime Minister has a plan. It’s called Get Britain Working, a strategy to increase employment by creating a new National Jobs and Careers Service, reforming the benefits system and providing youth employment guarantees, whatever they are.

However, there’s a hitch. Up to three million UK jobs in lower-skilled areas such as sales, customer service and administration could disappear by 2035, warns new research showing that the pace of change in the labour market is accelerating.

The analysis, by the National Foundation for Educational Research, found that employment in sales and customer service occupations, for instance, has fallen more than 10 per cent since 2021. Inevitably, AI is partly to blame.

Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer speaking to the media. PIC: Henry Nicholls/PA Wireplaceholder image
Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer speaking to the media. PIC: Henry Nicholls/PA Wire

Sir Keir Starmer has a 16-year-old son and a 13-year-old daughter. Wait until his offspring and their friends start trying to find a Saturday or holiday job, a part-time job to help fund their university studies, or heaven help them, a full-time job on graduation.

Students who graduated in the summer of 2023 into a slowing jobs market have fared worse than any other cohort since the start of the Covid-19 pandemic. Just 56.4 per cent of this cohort was in full-time employment 15 months after graduation, down from 59 per cent the previous year, according to research by Prospects at Jisc, an education data and technology group.

Meanwhile, there’s little seasonal cheer. Opposition leader Kemi Badenoch warns that Labour’s workers’ rights legislation will destroy Christmas jobs by putting firms off hiring seasonal workers.

The Employment Rights Bill, championed by former deputy Prime Minister Angela Rayner, contains measures such as the right to demand flexible working from day one.

In a speech to the CBI (Confederation of British Industry), Badenoch called such proposals “job-destroying” and said that the bill’s provision to give employees regular, consistent hours could have a major unintended consequence. Employers will simply stop hiring for short-term jobs.

Calling this a “de facto ban on seasonal and flexible work”, she said, “if a university undergrad chooses to get a Christmas job and works 40 hours a week in the three weeks before December, they then have the right to those same hours in January, February and March.”

The problem, Badenoch pointed out, is that “rational employers” would decide not to take on seasonal staff at all, be that for Christmas sales or hospitality or fruit-picking over the summer months, for example.

That’s another massive hole kicked out of employment for those in their late teens and early twenties. And believe me, it’s already difficult enough for this age group to find paid employment.

They’re applying for hundreds and hundreds of jobs, often with no acknowledgement from potential employers that an application has been received, never mind the prospect of an interview.

I call it the curse of Indeed, and other job search engines; as far as I’ve witnessed, uploading your CV to one of these is like throwing your educational achievements, work and life experience to date, into a black hole.

If this government is serious about young people finding jobs it needs to deploy a team as part of its National Jobs and Careers Service to examine exactly how this method of so-called recruitment operates, because most jobseekers will tell them that it is rarely successful.

What’s missing is the human touch and the power of personal communication. I saw this in action last weekend in a popular chain restaurant in York. Visiting with friends who have a student daughter in the city, we all went out for lunch.

Chatting with the young waiter, we discovered he was leaving for another job – he’d got it by personal recommendation - that day. My friend’s daughter, who has been desperately looking for part-time work, asked the manager if there was a new job going, and if so would he consider her?

When he said he wasn’t planning to hire a replacement for our waiter, she asked if she might pop by and leave her CV in case anything came up in future.

“Oh no,” the manager replied. “We can’t accept CVs due to GDPR (data protection), we only recruit via Indeed these days. And we won’t be recruiting until next year now anyway.”

At which my friend’s daughter’s face fell. She knows, as does almost every other student seeking work in the UK, that Indeed is rarely a magic solution to job-hunting woes.

News you can trust since 1754
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice