Post Office fraud scandal; why a public inquiry must be held – The Yorkshire Post says

“THE day I went to court and they sent me to jail, I remember them taking me into the cell but not much more because I cried that much. I was on suicide watch because of my emotional state.”

This heartbreaking testimony from Hull’s Janet Skinner, one of countless sub-postmasters wrongly convicted and jailed for fraud, helps to “humanise” Britain’s worst ever miscarriage of justice into context.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

It isn’t just how the Post Office placed more trust in its flawed Horizon IT system than postmasters regarded as pillars of community, and how this was routinely accepted by the courts, but the lives ruined by this injustice.

janet Skinner was one of the sub postmasters wrongly jailed in an IT fraud scandal that has become Britain's worst ever miscarriage of justice.janet Skinner was one of the sub postmasters wrongly jailed in an IT fraud scandal that has become Britain's worst ever miscarriage of justice.
janet Skinner was one of the sub postmasters wrongly jailed in an IT fraud scandal that has become Britain's worst ever miscarriage of justice.
Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Even now, more than two decades later, it is virtually impossible to ascertain the number of people wrongly convicted, the amount of time that they spent in prison, their collective loss of earnings – and legal costs.

What is abundantly clear, however, is that the Government’s current inquiry is totally inadequate and that a judge-led investigation must be set up to establish the truth and, if necessary, prosecute those officials who sanctioned the persecution of so many innocent postmasters when the Horizon system’s failings were so clear.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad
Lib dem leader Sir Ed davey was among those to be responsible for the Post Office during the IT scandal that led to Britain's worst ever miscarriage of justice.Lib dem leader Sir Ed davey was among those to be responsible for the Post Office during the IT scandal that led to Britain's worst ever miscarriage of justice.
Lib dem leader Sir Ed davey was among those to be responsible for the Post Office during the IT scandal that led to Britain's worst ever miscarriage of justice.

Not only would such an inquiry compel individuals like former Post Office chief executive Paula Vennells, who was ultimately rewarded with a CBE and a senior Cabinet Office role, to give evidence on oath, and in public, but it would force past and present politicians, like Lib Dem leader Sir Ed Davey, to account for their actions as Ministers in charge of postal affairs.

But there’s another point that must be put on record as victims are pushed from pillar to post – literally – by the establishment.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Unlike the behind-closed-doors inquiry being presided over by Sir Wyn Williams, a public inquiry would also allow every postmaster like Janet Skinner, jailed for nine months, to present evidence and have their reputations fully restored.

Paula Vennells CBE (left) is the disgraced former chief executive of the Post Office.Paula Vennells CBE (left) is the disgraced former chief executive of the Post Office.
Paula Vennells CBE (left) is the disgraced former chief executive of the Post Office.

Support The Yorkshire Post and become a subscriber today. Your subscription will help us to continue to bring quality news to the people of Yorkshire. In return, you’ll see fewer ads on site, get free access to our app and receive exclusive members-only offers. Click here to subscribe.

Comment Guidelines

National World encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.