Why we need leaders’ debates in general election after pointless PMQs and how they should work – The Yorkshire Post says

0
Have your say

IT IS harder to make the case for leaders’ debates during the General Election in the aftermath of Boris Johnson and Jeremy Corbyn’s toxic exchanges at the last Prime Minister’s Questions of this shambolic Parliament.

Yet it will be a disservice to democracy if disagreements about the rules of engagement stand in the way of the Prime Minister, Leader of the Opposition and other key players going head-to-head to debate the key issues.

Jeremy Corbyn (left) and Boris Johnson (right) should take place in leaders' debates, The Yorkshire Post argues.

Jeremy Corbyn (left) and Boris Johnson (right) should take place in leaders' debates, The Yorkshire Post argues.

Adam Boulton: Don’t let our leaders duck TV election debates if they want to win our votes

Such debates are customary in most democracies, notably the United States, and the regret is that there are no proper protocols in place nearly a decade after their introduction here during the 2010 election.

YP Letters: Political TV debate plans don’t go far enough

However, while many will contend, with reason, that such exchanges will provide an extension to the ritual trading of statistics, soundbites and insults that have so diminished PMQs, they will become more illuminating if the candidates for Prime Minister were being questioned by panels of experts and voters.

Nick Clegg, David Cameron and Gordon Brown took part in groundbreaking debates in the 2010 election.

Nick Clegg, David Cameron and Gordon Brown took part in groundbreaking debates in the 2010 election.

Questions of trust and Brexit for voters ahead of a December 12 general election – The Yorkshire Post says

Why not persuade the country’s top Brexit protagonists, and a cross-section of the population, to question the main leaders on the fine detail about Britain’s exit from the European Union?

Why not ask health and social care professionals, and also patients, to use their knowledge and insight to cross-examine the key candidates on the future of the NHS and care of the elderly?

And why not give the UK’s top economists, together with the owners of small businesses, a chance to scrutinise the many spending commitments which will be made in the coming days?

Boris Johnson - speaking at the last Prime Minister's Questions before the election.

Boris Johnson - speaking at the last Prime Minister's Questions before the election.

Chaired by a strong moderator, this has the potential to be far more constructive than PMQs which has become both predictable, and pointless, because Westminster’s partisanship has become so detrimental to the quality of political debate in the UK.